Types of Roofing Materials – Mistakes to Avoid + Better Fixes

Roofing comes in several main categories, each with its own feel and job. Asphalt shingles, metal, clay or concrete tile, slate, wood shakes, synthetic membranes, and flat-roof systems cover most homes. Think about climate, budget, and roof pitch when you start comparing options.

Each material has typical uses and a general lifespan range you can discuss with suppliers or installers. Use this overview to spot quick pros and cons and to guide questions you ask during product data sheet reviews. Don’t lock in on a single factor before you compare the full picture.

Asphalt shingles

Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material due to their affordability and ease of installation. They’re made from a fiberglass mat coated with asphalt and topped with granules.

Pros: Inexpensive, easy to install, and come in various styles and colors.

Cons: Short lifespan (15-30 years), susceptible to wind damage, and not eco-friendly. Common installation mistakes include nailing too high, which can cause shingles to curl up and blow off.

Metal roofing

Metal roofs are durable and long-lasting, made from steel, aluminum, or copper. Standing seam metal roofs have vertical panels with seams raised above the level of the panel’s flat area.

Pros: Long lifespan (40-70 years), energy-efficient, and low maintenance. They’re also resistant to fire, insects, and rot.

Cons: More expensive than asphalt shingles, can be noisy during rain, and may dent from hail or falling branches. Regular inspections are needed to check for rust or damaged panels.

Tile, slate, and masonry

Clay/concrete tiles and slate offer a classic, elegant look. They’re heavy (up to 800 lbs per square) and require a strong roof structure.

Pros: Long lifespan (50-100 years), fire-resistant, and provide good insulation. Slate is especially durable and low-maintenance.

Cons: Expensive to install due to their weight and complexity of installation. Tiles can break if walked on or during hail storms. Installation mistakes include using insufficient nails or not allowing for proper expansion.

Back to top ↑

Climate factors like wind, snow loads, hail, sun exposure, and humidity shape material suitability. Some products handle heat and UV better, while others resist moisture or cold better. Consider how your roof will perform year after year under local conditions.

Also check roof slope, fire rating, and local building codes. If you’re unsure about a rating or code requirement, verify with the manufacturer instructions or the local authority having jurisdiction. Look for safe ranges or options when exact specs aren’t available.

Hot, Sunny Climates

In hot, sunny climates, consider reflective or ‘cool’ roofs to reduce energy costs and heat gain. Dark colors absorb heat, so avoid them if possible.

Unvented assemblies can trap heat, leading to premature degradation of materials. Always ensure proper ventilation.

Clay tiles, metal, and light-colored asphalt shingles are good choices for hot climates. Consider using light colors or reflective coatings on metal roofs to maximize reflectivity.

Regularly inspect your roof for signs of heat damage, such as warping or cracking, especially in areas with high UV exposure.

Cold and Snowy Climates

In cold, snowy regions, choose materials that can shed snow effectively to prevent ice dams and excessive weight. Slate, metal, and composite shingles are good options.

Underlayment is crucial in cold climates. Use a high-quality, breathable underlayment to prevent moisture buildup and ice dams.

Proper insulation and ventilation are key in cold climates. Ensure your attic is well-insulated and properly ventilated to prevent heat buildup and ice dams.

Avoid using materials that can become brittle in extreme cold, such as some types of asphalt shingles or unmodified bitumen membranes.

Wind-, Hail-, and Fire-Prone Areas

In windy, hail-prone regions, choose impact-resistant materials like metal, tile, or Class 4 impact-resistant asphalt shingles.

Fastening patterns are crucial in high-wind areas. Use appropriate fasteners and follow recommended spacing to secure your roof against high winds.

In fire-prone regions, consider using fire-rated materials like metal, tile, or Class A asphalt shingles. Always check local building codes for specific fire-resistant material requirements.

Avoid using highly combustible materials in fire-prone areas. Regularly inspect and maintain your roof to minimize potential fire hazards.

Back to top ↑

Upfront costs vary by material and installation complexity. Long-term value depends on durability, maintenance, and repair needs. Use this lens to weigh initial price against life expectancy and performance in your climate.

Judge repair costs and intervals by material type and local labor rates. When you need precise figures, consult a pro for estimates and check warranty terms. If uncertain, base decisions on ranges you verify with product labels or manufacturer guides.

Upfront vs lifecycle costs

The first thing you’ll notice is the upfront cost. Asphalt shingles are cheapest, while slate and tile are most expensive.

But don’t stop there. Consider maintenance and repairs over time. Metal roofs need less frequent repair than asphalt, but they can dent from hail or falling branches.

Energy savings matter too. Light-colored roofs reflect heat in hot climates, saving on cooling costs. Insulated roofs help in cold climates.

Tip: Calculate the total cost over 15-30 years to see the true value of each material.

Warranty and insurance considerations

Check warranties carefully. Some cover only manufacturing defects, not labor or materials. Others offer prorated coverage that decreases over time.

Material choice can affect insurance premiums. Impact-resistant roofs can lower premiums in hail-prone areas. Class 4 impact-resistant asphalt shingles are a good option here.

In wildfire zones, consider fire-resistant materials like metal or tile to reduce risk and potentially save on insurance.

Pro tip: Consult with your insurer before choosing a roof material to understand potential discounts or increased risks.

Back to top ↑

Common mistakes include poor flashing detail, insufficient underlayment, wrong fastener type or pattern, and improper ventilation. These issues often stem from cost-cutting or skipping a critical step in the process. They can shorten roof life and invite leaks.

Root causes also include misreading slope requirements or ignoring local code nuances. Use this as a diagnostic list to spot vulnerabilities in a bid or plan. Always confirm installation requirements with labeled product instructions or code references.

Flashing and penetration failures

Incorrect flashing techniques around chimneys, vents, valleys, and skylights can lead to moisture problems that shorten your roof’s life. Water finds the path of least resistance, so without proper sealing, it can seep in and cause rot, mold, or ice dams.

Chimney flashings should be securely attached with counter-flashing on the chimney itself to prevent water intrusion. Vent flashings need to be tight around each vent pipe, using a rubber boot or metal flashing that’s sealed properly. Valleys and skylights require careful attention too – ensure they’re well-sealed and sloped for water runoff.

Using the wrong materials or cutting corners here can cost you dearly in repairs down the road. Always use high-quality flashing and follow manufacturer guidelines for best results.

Ventilation and insulation mismatches

Poor attic ventilation and insulation choices can lead to ice dams, rot, and energy loss – all enemies of a long-lasting roof. Proper balance between the two is key.

Insufficient ventilation traps heat in your attic, causing snow melt that refreezes at the eaves, forming ice dams. This can lead to leaks and damage. Too much insulation without proper ventilation does the same thing – it traps heat, leading to similar problems.

To avoid these issues, follow these guidelines: install a continuous ridge vent with soffit vents for intake; use baffles at the eaves to prevent insulation from blocking airflow; and insulate your attic floor to keep heat out in summer and in during winter. This helps maintain a cool, dry attic year-round.

Practical fixes start with safety and a solid assessment. Replacing damaged shingles, resealing flashings, and clearing gutters are common tasks homeowners can handle with basic tools. Apply only what you’re confident performing without exposing yourself to hazards.

Follow a stepwise approach: prep, remove damaged material, clean, and reattach with proper fasteners and sealant. When in doubt about material specifics, check the product label or manufacturer instructions. If a repair feels beyond your skill, hire a pro.

Shingle replacement and patching

Safety first: wear gloves, safety glasses, and a sturdy ladder. Tie it off for stability.

Remove damaged shingles carefully, keeping surrounding ones intact. Match the new one to the old, both in size and color. Apply roofing cement under the tabs of the new shingle before nailing it down.

Seal around the new shingle with more cement to prevent water intrusion. Use a caulking gun for best control.

Flashing repair and resealing

Inspect your flashings – around chimneys, vents, and skylights. If they’re loose or cracked, reseal with new flashing cement. For major damage, replace the entire flashing.

Use a putty knife to apply a thick bead of sealant along the base of the flashing. Smooth it out with your finger, wearing gloves for protection.

Check your work after a rainstorm. If water’s getting in, you may need professional help.

Temporary vs permanent fixes for emergencies

For sudden leaks, use a tarp to cover the damaged area. Secure it with weights or ropes, not nails that could cause more damage.

Seal small holes temporarily with roofing tar or silicone caulk. But remember, these are temporary fixes. Get a professional out within 2-3 weeks for permanent repairs.

If water’s coming in heavily, turn off power to the affected area to prevent electrical hazards. Then, contain the water with buckets or towels until you can make proper repairs.

Back to top ↑

Understand wind, fire, and impact classifications in homeowner terms. Translate labels and ASTM/NFPA references into practical expectations for your roof. This helps with selecting materials suited to your area.

Permits are often required for significant roof work; verify with your local building department. Track what to check on official documents and when to ask for official approvals. If you aren’t sure about a standard, ask the manufacturer or local authority for guidance.

Understanding Ratings and Labels

When shopping for roofing materials, you’ll see various ratings and labels. Let’s break down the common ones to help you make informed decisions.

Fire Classifications: These are rated A, B, or C based on their resistance to fire. Class A is the most resistant, providing the best protection for your home.

ASTM Numbers: ASTM International sets standards for materials and products. When you see an ASTM number (like D3018 for asphalt shingles), it means the product meets certain quality and performance criteria.

UL Listings: Underwriters Laboratories tests and certifies products for safety and performance. A UL listing ensures your roofing material has been independently tested and approved.

When You Need Permits and Inspections

Before starting any major roofing project, check with your local building department. Here’s a quick checklist to help you determine when permits are required.

Back to top ↑

Set a seasonal rhythm for inspections and camera or photo notes of wear. Look for curling, missing granules, rust, or loosening along edges. Early signs are cheaper to address than large failures.

Plan maintenance intervals around material type and local conditions. Note any immediate action signs like leaks or damaged flashing. When uncertain, reference manufacturer care sheets or labeling for maintenance steps.

Long-Term Maintenance Tasks

Regular upkeep ensures your roof lasts as long as possible. Here’s a list of tasks to keep your roof in tip-top shape.

• Gutter cleaning: Clean gutters twice a year – once in spring and again in fall. Clogged gutters can cause water damage to your roof and home.
• Moss removal: Remove moss from your roof annually. Moss holds moisture, which can damage shingles over time.
• Fastener checks: Inspect metal fasteners every few years. Tighten or replace any that are loose or missing to prevent leaks.
• Professional inspections: Schedule a professional inspection every 3-5 years. They can spot issues you might miss.

Quick rule: Regular maintenance is cheaper than repairs.

Back to top ↑

Vet roofers by checking licenses, insurance, and project portfolios. Ask questions about material choices, installation methods, and warranty coverage. Compare not just price, but the scope of work and promised outcomes.

Request a written bid with a clear breakdown of materials, labor, and timescales. Include a list of documents to provide and red flags to watch for. If you’re unsure about a claim, verify with the product data sheet or manufacturer instructions.

Questions to ask and red flags

First off, always ask for their license number. They should be insured too – liability and workers’ comp.

Ask about their experience with the specific material you’re using. If they’ve never worked with it before, find someone who has.

Beware of bids that are way lower than others. It might mean they’re cutting corners or not including everything in their quote. No written contract? That’s a red flag too.

Evaluating bids and contracts

When comparing bids, check the scope of work. Make sure they’re all covering the same stuff. Materials should be specified too – you don’t want cheap substitutes.

Warranties matter. Some contractors might offer longer warranties than others. Same goes for cleanup – some might include it, others might not.

Payment schedules vary too. Some might ask for a big chunk upfront, others might have a more reasonable schedule. Read the fine print and make sure you’re comfortable with it before signing anything.

Back to top ↑