Replacing a Broken Tile – DIY Steps + Stop Points

This article covers how to replace a broken tile from start to finish. It explains when a DIY fix is feasible and when to call a pro based on tile type and damage extent. You’ll also get a sense of the workload and a rough time range to gauge readiness.

Consider the condition of the subfloor and moisture exposure before deciding to DIY. Check the tile’s location and any potential risk to surrounding work. If you’re unsure, verify product labels, manufacturer instructions, or local rules before proceeding.

When a broken tile is a simple DIY

A single cracked or chipped tile, or one that’s loose but not crumbling, are usually straightforward fixes for the average homeowner.

These jobs typically don’t require special tools or skills. Just remember, safety first. Wear gloves and protect your eyes when handling broken pieces.

Risk factors like tiles near heat sources (stove, fireplace) or in high-traffic areas can make the job trickier. But with care, these are manageable DIY projects.

When to call a professional

Water damage behind tiles is a big red flag. It could indicate mold growth or structural issues that need pro attention.

Large areas of damaged tiles, especially if they’re specialty types (like hand-painted or mosaic), might be best left to the pros. They have access to matching materials and know-how to maintain patterns.

If you notice structural movement – like walls or floors shifting – don’t DIY. This could indicate serious underlying issues that require professional assessment.

Back to top ↑

Start with a prioritized list of tools like a basic set of hand tools, chisels, and spacers. Include a selection of consumables such as replacement tiles and appropriate adhesive. Note safer alternatives for renters or tight budgets, like rental tools or generic glue options where applicable.

Keep a box of safety gear handy and a small container for waste. Have a moisture meter or test method if you suspect water damage, and confirm compatible adhesives with the tile type and substrate. Always check labels, data sheets, or manufacturer instructions for specifics.

Begin with a quick safety check of the work area and equipment. Verify that the nearest water and electrical services are shut off if required. If anything seems uncertain, pause and confirm before proceeding.

Test the substrate soundness in the area around the damaged tile. If the subfloor or backing shows softness or crumble, stop and reassess the plan. Always consult the manufacturer instructions or local codes for any special prep requirements.

Personal protective equipment and workspace protection

Safety first, buddy. Protect yourself and your space before you start.

• Eye Protection: Wear safety glasses or goggles to keep debris out of your eyes. They’re cheap, so don’t skimp.
• Gloves: Use work gloves to protect your hands from cuts and scrapes. Leather or heavy-duty fabric gloves are best.
• Dust Mask: A simple dust mask will keep you breathing easy. For heavier duty, consider a respirator around $20-$30.
• Drop Cloths: Lay down drop cloths or old sheets to protect nearby surfaces and cabinets from falling debris.
• Plastic Sheeting: Use plastic sheeting to cover fixtures like sinks and toilets. It’s a few bucks at any hardware store.

Verifying substrate condition

Before you start tearing out tiles, make sure the surface underneath is solid as a rock. Here’s how to check:

Gently Tap: Use a wooden or plastic taping tool (around $5) and gently tap on the tiles around the broken one. Listen for hollow sounds. If you hear any, it might mean there’s damage under the surface.

Check for Soft Spots: Press firmly on the tiles with your hands. If any feel soft or give way, that’s a sign of trouble. You might need to repair the substrate before replacing the tile.

Look for Cracks and Holes: Inspect the area closely for any cracks, holes, or other signs of damage. If you see any, you’ll need to address those first.

Back to top ↑

Score the grout around the damaged tile to isolate it. Use a putty knife or grout saw to open up the joints without prying nearby tiles. Gently break the tile, working from the center outward to minimize damage.

Check progress after each small step to ensure adjacent tiles remain intact. If you encounter hard spots or suspect adhesive failure, pause and reassess. Reference product labels or instructions if you need a specific removal method for your tile brand.

Removing grout and loosening the tile

Start by scoring the grout around the broken tile using a grout saw or oscillating tool. This helps prevent chipping adjacent tiles when you remove the tile.

Be careful not to apply too much pressure, which could cause the surrounding tiles to crack. If you feel resistance, stop and adjust your technique.

Once the grout is scored, use a flathead screwdriver or pry bar to gently lift one corner of the tile. This should break the seal between the tile and the adhesive bed. Work slowly and carefully to avoid breaking the tile into smaller pieces.

Extracting tile shards and cleaning the void

After loosening the tile, use a hammer and chisel to carefully break it into smaller pieces. Work from one corner towards the center, stopping if you encounter resistance to avoid damaging the substrate.

Be cautious when prying out the broken pieces with a flathead screwdriver or pry bar. Lift slowly and steadily to prevent further cracking or damage to surrounding tiles.

Once all tile shards are removed, use a wire brush or scraper to clean the adhesive bed and substrate. Inspect for any damage or weak spots before proceeding with the replacement process. If you find significant damage, consider calling a professional to assess the situation.

Back to top ↑

Inspect the substrate for cracks, softness, or water damage. If you find loose or crumbling backing, plan for repair before continuing. Treat any substrate issues as a gatekeeper before moving on to tile replacement.

Decide whether you need to patch thinset, replace a section of backerboard, or address moisture concerns. If you’re unsure about the extent, stop and verify with the substrate manufacturer guidance or local building rules. Keep notes to guide repairs if you need to involve a pro later.

Small patch repairs

If your substrate has minor dips or shallow depressions, you can fix them using patching compounds. These fillers are designed to level out surfaces and create a smooth base for new tiles.

First, clean the area thoroughly. Then, apply the compound with a trowel, following the manufacturer’s instructions for thickness. Use a straight edge to scrape off excess material and ensure a flat surface.

Allow the patch to cure as directed by the product label. This typically takes 24-72 hours. Check for flatness before proceeding with tile installation.

When to replace backerboard or address rot

Sometimes, the damage goes beyond simple patching. If your substrate feels soft or spongy, shows signs of mold, or has widespread damage, it’s time to replace the backerboard.

Softness indicates water damage, which can compromise the structural integrity of your wall or floor. Mold growth suggests moisture issues that could lead to further problems if left untreated. Widespread damage means there are too many patches needed, making replacement more practical.

If you find any of these issues, stop work immediately. Water damage and mold require professional assessment and remediation. Once the area is dry and safe, replace the affected backerboard with new, following proper installation techniques to prevent future problems.

Back to top ↑

Choose the adhesive that matches your tile and substrate. Apply and back-butter or butter the tile as needed to achieve even coverage. Align the tile carefully with spacers to maintain a consistent grid height.

Check the tile height relative to surrounding tiles and ensure levelness across the plane. If you spot potential alignment or adhesion issues, pause and verify the instructions from the adhesive or tile manufacturer. Recheck labeling and local code requirements before final setting.

Adhesive application and setting technique

First, choose the right adhesive. For most jobs, thin-set mortar is your best bet. It’s strong, flexible, and water-resistant. Mastic might be fine for light-duty areas like backsplashes, but avoid it on floors.

Use a notched trowel to apply the adhesive. The size of the notch depends on tile size: 1/4″ for tiles up to 6×6″, 3/8″ for larger ones. Spread it out with the smooth side of the trowel, then comb through with the notched side.

Press the tile firmly into the adhesive, wiggling it slightly to ensure full contact. Hold it there for a few seconds to let the bond set.

Leveling, spacing, and temporary cure checks

Use spacers between tiles to maintain even grout lines. The standard size is 1/8″, but you can adjust based on your tile’s size and desired look.

Check for lippage – where one tile is higher than another. Tap down any high spots with a rubber mallet. You want all tiles level with each other.

Before grouting, let the adhesive cure. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions, but typically this takes 24-72 hours. Once cured, do a light test by gently tapping on the tile with a coin. If it sounds solid, you’re good to go.

Back to top ↑

Mix and apply grout per the manufacturer’s guidance, working in small sections. Tool the joints to the correct shape and wipe away excess grout as you go. Allow a partial cure window before full cleanup to improve finish and color alignment.

Finish by removing haze and sealing grout if recommended for your material. If grout cracking or improper setup appears, pause and assess the need for rework or professional help. Always verify grout specifications with product data sheets or instructions.

Back to top ↑

Address issues like loose tiles, cracking grout, or lippage with targeted fixes and rechecking alignment. Decide whether to redo the tile section or escalate to a pro based on the severity. Use practical, take-it-in-steps judgment to avoid repeating mistakes.

When color mismatch or unexpected movement occurs, compare options against your chosen tile and adhesive specifications. If in doubt, pause and verify guidance from the tile or adhesive maker, or consult local regulations for acceptable remediation steps.

Dealing with loose or hollow-sounding tiles

If your newly installed tile sounds hollow when tapped, it’s likely that there are voids underneath or the adhesive wasn’t applied properly. Here’s how to fix this:

Check for voids: Tap the tile gently. If it sounds hollow, use a screwdriver to poke small holes in the grout lines until you find the void.

Inject adhesive: Once you’ve located the void, inject thinset or construction adhesive into the hole using a caulking gun with a nozzle attachment. This will fill the void and secure the tile.

If injecting adhesive doesn’t work, or if the tile is still loose, it’s best to remove and reinstall the tile properly. See our earlier section on ‘Installing the Replacement Tile’ for detailed steps.

Fixing grout cracks, stains, or mismatches

Grout can crack over time due to movement in the substrate, or it might stain or mismatch with your existing grout. Here’s how to fix these issues:

Cracks: If the grout has cracked, you’ll need to regrout. First, remove the old grout using a grout saw or oscillating tool. Then, clean the area and apply new grout.

Stains: For stains, try cleaning the grout with a mixture of water and bleach (1 part bleach to 3 parts water). If that doesn’t work, you might need to recolor or seal the grout. See our earlier section on ‘Grout selection and application tips’ for more information.

Mismatches: To blend mismatched grout, try cleaning the old grout with a mixture of water and muriatic acid (follow safety guidelines). Then, apply a grout colorant to match your existing grout. If the mismatch is significant, it might be best to regrout the entire area.

Back to top ↑