Repairing Broken Control Joints: Clean-Out, Backer Rod, and Sealant Steps

Assess the joint for signs of failure that go beyond surface cracks. Look for recurring movement, hollow spots, or concrete delamination that weaken the edge. If the substrate feels soft or crumbles, replacement is likely the safer route.

Consider whether adjacent materials show damage or if the joint has been repeatedly disturbed by movement. Check if any structural elements nearby appear compromised. When in doubt, verify with the project specs or instruction sheets to decide if repair alone will hold up.

Assessing the joint condition

First, take a good look at your control joint. It’s like checking under the hood of a car – you gotta see what’s going on.

Check for adhesion loss. If the concrete is pulling away from itself or other surfaces, that’s a bad sign. It might be time to replace rather than repair.

Look out for substrate spalling. That’s when chunks of concrete are flaking off. Again, not good. This could mean the joint needs replacing.

Gently wiggle or push on the joint. If there’s too much movement – more than a few millimeters – it might be best to replace it. Excessive movement can lead to further damage and make repairs less effective.

Common causes of joint failure

Control joints are designed to control where concrete cracks naturally. But sometimes they fail. Here’s why:

One, too much movement. Concrete expands and contracts with temperature changes. If the joint can’t handle it, it’ll crack.

Two, weathering. Rain, snow, freeze-thaw cycles – they all take a toll on concrete over time. Joints aren’t immune.

Three, improper original installation. If the joint wasn’t cut deep enough or filled properly, it won’t do its job right.

Four, incompatible materials. Using the wrong type of sealant or backer rod can cause the joint to fail. Make sure you’re using the right stuff for your specific concrete and climate.

Back to top ↑

Put on basic PPE such as eye protection, gloves, and a dust mask before starting. Keep the work area contained to minimize dust and debris. Use drop cloths or plastic to protect nearby finishes.

Set up containment for waste and dust control to prevent runoff. Establish a clear path for clean tools and debris removal. Confirm any local rules or label directions on products for safe handling.

Personal Protective Equipment

Safety first, buddy. Here’s what you need to protect yourself while repairing those broken control joints.

• Gloves: Protect your hands from concrete dust and chemicals. Disposable gloves are cheap (around $5/pack of 100).
• Eye Protection: Safety glasses or goggles keep dust out of your eyes. Consider a full-face shield if you’re using power tools.
• Respirator: For solvent-based removers, use an N95 respirator or a half-face respirator with P100 filters ($20-$30).
• Ear Protection: If you’re using power tools, wear earplugs to protect your hearing.
• Clothing: Wear old clothes that cover your skin. Long sleeves and long pants are a must.

Environmental and Substrate Prep

Before you start, make sure the weather’s on your side and protect nearby surfaces from damage.

Weather: Repair joints when temperatures are between 50°F and 90°F. Avoid rain or high humidity to prevent issues with sealant adhesion.

Mask off nearby surfaces with painter’s tape and plastic sheeting. This protects adjacent finishes from dust and sealant spills. A roll of tape is around $3, and a pack of 10 sheets of plastic is about $5.

Substrate Prep: Ensure the joint surface is clean and dry before you start. Remove any loose material or debris with a wire brush or scraper.

Back to top ↑

Gather the essential demolition and cleaning tools, plus a reliable backer rod and a compatible sealant. Have a few optional items on hand for tight spots or budget choices. Keep a few disposable brushes or rags for quick cleanup.

Include a caulking gun, putty knife, and a squeegee or tool for smooth tooling. Bring a ruler or depth gauge to check profiles, and a small vacuum for dust control. If unsure about specs, check manufacturer instructions or product data sheets for details.

Sealant and backer rod selection

Choosing the right sealant and backer rod is crucial for a successful repair. Here’s what to consider.

• Sealant chemistry: Match it with your existing joint material (e.g., silicone, polyurethane).
• Sealant color: Choose one that blends with your concrete.
• Backer rod size: Measure your joint width to get the right diameter.
• Backer rod material: Consider if you need closed-cell (waterproof) or open-cell foam.
• Manufacturer compatibility: Check charts to ensure sealant and backer rod work together.

Quick rule: Always check manufacturer guidelines for best results.

Optional supplies

These extras can enhance your repair job’s finish and durability. Consider adding them to your toolkit.

• Joint primer: Improves sealant adhesion, especially on damp surfaces.
• Release tape: Keeps excess sealant off the concrete surface during application.
• Solvent wipes: Clean up any sealant residue after application.
• Joint measurement gauge: Ensures consistent backer rod insertion depth for even sealant application.

Quick rule: Optional supplies can make your job easier and look better – but they’re not always necessary.

Back to top ↑

Understand the basic attributes that matter in joints: movement capability, adhesion to substrates, and elasticity. Look for products labeled for exterior or interior use as appropriate, and that suit joint movement you expect. Do not rely on color alone to judge suitability.

Clarify any local requirements or standards by checking the product label, the data sheet, or code guidance. Compare how the product performs under conditions similar to your project. If in doubt, ask the supplier or review the manufacturer’s instructions.

Sealant Performance Attributes

The tech data sheet is your friend here. Look for these key attributes:

Movement Range: This tells you how much the joint can open and close before the sealant fails. For control joints, aim for a range of at least 25% to accommodate typical movement.

Shore Hardness: This measures the sealant’s resistance to indentation. A higher number means harder. You want something in the medium range (around 40-60) for control joints – hard enough to resist wear, but soft enough to move with the joint.

Adhesion: Look for a high adhesion rating (like ‘excellent’ or ‘outstanding’). This ensures your sealant sticks well to the concrete. Check if it’s suitable for your specific substrate too.

Backer Rod Properties and Sizing Guidance

Backer rods come in two main types:

Closed-cell: These are more rigid, providing better support for wider joints. They’re less compressible but offer good resistance to water and chemicals.

Open-cell: These are softer and more compressible, ideal for narrower joints. They absorb moisture though, so they’re not as durable.

When choosing a backer rod, consider the joint width and depth. Most manufacturers provide sizing charts. Here’s a simple guide to get you started:

– For narrow joints (up to 1/2″ wide), use a small diameter rod (around 3/8″ or 1/2″).
– For wider joints, opt for larger diameters (3/4″ to 1″ or more).

Back to top ↑

Begin by removing old sealant and loose debris with a suitable tool while protecting the joint faces. Dig down to sound substrate and stop where the edge remains stable. Do not gouge or widen the crack beyond what is necessary.

After removing material, inspect the wall for any signs of damage or moisture. Note any soft spots or spalling and plan repairs accordingly. Use manufacturer guidance to determine when the surface is ready for the next step.

Removing old sealant and debris

Safely removing old sealant and debris is crucial for a successful repair. Here’s how to do it right.

Mechanical cutting or controlled chiseling are your best bets for removing old sealant without damaging the joint faces. Use a chisel and hammer, working carefully along the joint line.

For stubborn sealant, use a heat gun to soften it before removal. Be cautious not to overheat and damage the substrate. Always wear appropriate PPE when using power tools or heat sources.

Dispose of removed sealant and debris responsibly, following local waste management guidelines. Never leave construction waste lying around.

Cleaning substrate and checking dimensions

Thoroughly cleaning the substrate ensures proper adhesion of your new sealant. Here’s how to do it right.

Use a stiff-bristled brush or compressed air to remove any remaining dust, residue, or small debris from the joint. For tougher residue, use a suitable solvent like acetone or denatured alcohol, following manufacturer’s instructions and safety guidelines.

Once clean, measure the joint width and depth accurately using a tape measure or ruler. This ensures you select the correct backer rod size and apply the right volume of sealant for an effective repair.

Pro tip: Measure at multiple points along the joint to account for any irregularities in the substrate. If measurements vary significantly, consult with a pro before proceeding.

Back to top ↑

Select a backer rod size that fits snugly in the joint without bottoming out. Insert it evenly so the rod sits at the proper depth for the expected joint profile. Avoid twisting or compressing the rod too aggressively, which can cause gaps later.

Check that the rod covers three sides of the joint properly and does not extend onto the faces. If you need to adjust depth, recheck with a quick test fit. Rely on product instructions to confirm acceptable compression and depth guidelines.

Choosing correct diameter and material

The backer rod you choose affects how well your seal holds up. Get this wrong, and you’ll see cracks or stains later.

• Closed-cell backer rod: Used for wider joints (1/4″ to 1″). Key spec: Look for a density of 2-3 lb/ft³. Tip: It’s waterproof but can be more expensive.
• Open-cell backer rod: For narrower joints (1/8″ to 1/4″). Key spec: Density around 1 lb/ft³. Tip: Cheaper, but less durable and not waterproof.
• Foam backer rod: A budget option for narrow joints (1/8″ to 3/8″). Key spec: Look for a compression rate of 20-40%. Tip: Avoid if joint width varies; it can compress too much or not enough.
• Polyethylene backer rod: For wider, deep joints (1/4″ to 3″). Key spec: Thickness should be slightly larger than the joint. Tip: Don’t use in high-traffic areas; it can wear out quickly.
• Silicone backer rod: A premium option for all joint widths. Key spec: Look for a Shore A hardness of 30-50. Tip: More expensive, but very durable and flexible.

Pro tip: Buy backer rod in small quantities to avoid waste. Store it in a cool, dry place. Before installing, check the joint width and choose a rod that’s slightly oversized for a snug fit.

Back to top ↑

Prime only if the product requires it, following the label instructions. Apply a continuous bead with steady pressure and keep the nozzle at a consistent angle. Tool the bead with a suitable tool to achieve a smooth, convex shape and full contact with the sides.

Avoid trapping air pockets by working in small sections and verifying the bead stays within the joint gutters. Check adhesion with a light touch after tooling to confirm a uniform finish. If possible, perform a compatibility test before full application.

Priming and adhesion prep

Using a primer can enhance sealant performance. It’s recommended when surfaces are porous, contaminated, or have poor adhesion properties.

Before applying the primer, follow manufacturer instructions for surface preparation. This usually involves cleaning, degreasing, and allowing the surface to dry completely.

Adhesion Test: Before priming the entire joint, perform a small adhesion test on a hidden area. Apply sealant, let it cure, then try to remove it. If it peels off easily, use a primer.

Gun technique, bead size, and tooling

The right application technique ensures a smooth, even sealant bead that adheres well to the joint faces.

• Steady Gun Movement: Hold the gun at a 45-degree angle to the joint. Apply sealant in a steady, smooth motion, keeping the gun moving at a consistent speed.
• Bead Size: The bead size should match the joint dimensions. As a general rule, use a bead that’s about half the width of the joint.
• Tooling: Immediately after applying the sealant, use a tool to shape it and press it into contact with the joint faces. A plastic spreader or a damp sponge works well for this. This ensures intimate contact and a strong bond.
• Optional Tools: You can rent tools like sealant applicators or tooling combs for a more professional finish. These typically cost around $20-$50 per day to rent.

Back to top ↑

Monitor cure under the product guidance, keeping traffic away and protecting from moisture as required. Inspect the finished joint for uniform profile and good surface finish. Look for consistent edges and no obvious gaps along the sides.

Carry out practical quality checks such as adhesion feel and edge integrity before final use. Note any required protective measures and timelines per the manufacturer instructions. If you see issues, verify with the product label or data sheet before proceeding.

Cure factors and protection

Before you let traffic or water hit your newly sealed joint, check these factors to ensure a solid cure.

Visual and dimensional acceptance criteria

Before signing off on the job, use this checklist to ensure your joint looks and measures right.

Back to top ↑