Air-Entrained vs Non-Air-Entrained Concrete: What to Order for Freeze-Thaw Areas

Air-entrained concrete contains intentionally created microscopic air voids dispersed through the paste, while non-air-entrained concrete has no planned microbubbles and is generally denser. The difference is physical: entrained mixes carry a controlled population of tiny, stable voids created during batching, whereas non-entrained mixes rely on the natural pore structure and have far fewer intentional voids.

Entrainment is introduced by adding an air-entraining admixture at the mixer and following proper mixing sequence and timing so agents form stable bubbles; temperature and mixing energy affect bubble formation and stability. For practical ordering, specify that the supplier provide air content targets, reference the relevant product data sheet or batching ticket, and confirm test methods used to verify the air-void system at batching and before placement.

What is air-entrained concrete?

Air-entrained concrete is a type of concrete that contains a controlled volume of microscopic air bubbles distributed throughout the mix. These tiny voids, measuring around 20 to 50 microns in diameter, are intentionally introduced by adding air-entraining admixtures during mixing.

Why air? The air bubbles act like tiny shock absorbers. When water freezes and expands, it has room to do so within these voids instead of putting pressure on the concrete’s structure.

This makes air-entrained concrete ideal for areas with freeze-thaw cycles. It helps prevent cracking and scaling due to freezing temperatures.

What is non-air-entrained concrete?

Non-air-entrained concrete, also known as normal concrete, does not have these intentional air voids. It’s a standard mix designed for general use where freeze-thaw resistance isn’t a primary concern.

When to use it? Non-air-entrained concrete is typically used in areas with mild climates or indoor applications where freezing temperatures aren’t an issue. It’s also used when high strength and low permeability are required, as the absence of air voids can improve these properties.

However, in freeze-thaw zones, non-air-entrained concrete may be more susceptible to damage from freezing and thawing cycles.

How entrainment is created and controlled

Entrainment is introduced through the use of air-entraining admixtures during concrete mixing. These chemicals create stable foam that gets evenly distributed throughout the mix, forming microscopic air bubbles.

The mixing procedure also plays a role. Proper mixing ensures even distribution of the air bubbles and helps achieve the desired level of entrainment.

Monitoring and testing are crucial to control air content. Air content is measured using methods like the pressure meter or volumetric methods at the batching plant and on-site before placement. This ensures the concrete meets the specified air content targets, usually between 4% to 7%.

Back to top ↑

Freeze-thaw damage happens when pore water freezes, expands, and creates internal pressure that drives cracking, scaling, and spalling in exposed concrete. An effective air-void system gives that expanding ice someplace to go, reducing internal stresses and slowing deterioration under repeated cycles.

Deicing salts can accelerate surface scaling and allow chlorides to reach reinforcing steel, so mixes used where salts are present should be specified for freeze-thaw exposure and salt contact. Check the mix’s target air content and confirm field or lab testing (see the supplier’s testing protocol or product data sheet) plus proper placement and curing to protect the air-void system during construction.

Mechanisms of freeze-thaw damage

In cold climates, concrete faces a tough enemy: the freeze-thaw cycle. Here’s how it damages your pour:

First, water in those tiny capillary pores freezes. As ice forms, it expands, creating immense internal pressure.

This pressure drives cracks through the paste, leading to scaling and spalling on the surface. It’s like a thousand tiny explosions happening inside your concrete.

Salt, from deicing agents, makes things worse. Chlorides penetrate deep, accelerating scaling and spalling.

How entrained air mitigates damage

Air-entrained concrete fights back against freeze-thaw with a secret weapon: tiny air voids.

These sub-micron to micron-sized bubbles, evenly distributed throughout the mix, provide relief space for freezing water. When ice forms and expands, it has room to grow without busting the concrete apart.

The result? Reduced internal stress, less cracking, and significantly improved resistance to surface scaling. It’s like giving the ice a comfortable place to stretch out, rather than having it fight against the concrete.

And here’s where those air voids really shine: they connect with each other, forming a network that helps water escape during thawing. This further reduces pressure and prevents damage.

Back to top ↑

Air-entrained concrete offers clear freeze-thaw durability benefits because its distributed microbubbles relieve expansion pressure and limit crack propagation, making it the typical choice for exterior slabs and pavements in freezing climates. However, entrainment can change finishing behavior and may require adjustments in finishing technique and curing to avoid surface defects.

Non-air-entrained concrete can provide denser packing and different surface characteristics favored for some indoor slabs or high-finish applications but is more vulnerable to freeze-thaw damage when exposed to moisture and salts. When deciding, list exposure conditions to your supplier, confirm target air-void content and testing methods, and use finish and curing practices suited to the chosen mix to mitigate trade-offs.

Benefits of air-entrained concrete

Air-entrained concrete (AEC) is your best bet for freeze-thaw resistance. Here’s why:

Improved Durability: Air voids in AEC act like tiny shock absorbers. When water freezes and expands, these voids give it room to move, preventing damage.

Resistance to Scaling: Deicers can cause surface scaling on concrete. But with AEC, the air voids help prevent this by relieving the pressure from ice formation.

Long-Term Durability: In exposed environments, AEC holds up better over time due to its enhanced freeze-thaw resistance.

Drawbacks and limitations of air-entrained concrete

AEC has some trade-offs. Keep these in mind:

Finishability: Too much air can make it harder to achieve a smooth finish. You might need to adjust your mix design.

Excessive or uncontrolled air content can lead to strength loss and slower strength development. It’s crucial to control the air content during mixing.

Too many air voids can also cause bleed water to rise to the surface, affecting the finish and potentially leading to micro-cracking.

When non-air-entrained concrete may be acceptable

Non-air-entrained concrete (NAEC) has its place, but it’s not suitable for all situations:

Low Exposure: If your project is indoors or in a protected area with minimal freeze-thaw cycles, NAEC might work.

NAEC can be a good choice for interior floors where finish quality and surface hardness are priorities. But remember, it’s not as durable under freeze-thaw conditions.

If you’re using alternative protections like sealers or heating systems to prevent freezing, NAEC could be an option. But these methods should be reliable and well-maintained.

Back to top ↑

Decide based on climate severity (frequency and intensity of freeze-thaw cycles), exposure to moisture and deicing salts, the structural role of the element, and the expected service life and maintenance plan. Sections exposed to repeated freezing and water—or subject to salts—generally need air-entrained concrete; interior, dry, or sealed elements may not.

Make a short checklist before ordering: local freeze-thaw severity, expected moisture/salt exposure, structural load class, and desired service life, then specify air content targets and necessary testing on the order ticket. Also consult applicable codes and the product data sheet or supplier guidance to confirm minimum air requirements and any seasonal adjustments before batching.

Climate and exposure considerations

In cold climates, the severity of winter plays a crucial role in choosing between air-entrained and non-air-entrained concrete. Freeze-thaw cycles, precipitation patterns, and deicing salt use are key factors.

First, consider your area’s average and extreme temperatures. More severe winters require more protection. For instance, areas with frequent sub-zero temperatures need higher air void content in their concrete.

Next, look at the number of freeze-thaw cycles. More cycles mean greater damage potential. In such cases, opt for air-entrained concrete to mitigate damage.

Lastly, consider deicing salt use. Salts speed up corrosion and increase the need for air entrainment. If salts are prevalent in your area, lean towards air-entrained mixes.

Project-specific factors (design, geometry, drainage)

The design and details of your project also influence concrete choice. Slab thickness, for example, affects freeze-thaw resistance. Thinner slabs need more protection.

Jointing and drainage are critical too. Properly spaced joints help control cracking, reducing damage from freezing and thawing. Good drainage prevents water buildup, which can lead to frost heave.

Permeability is another factor. More permeable concrete allows water in, increasing the risk of freeze-thaw damage. Consider using air-entrained mixes for higher permeability projects.

Surface finish matters too. Exposed aggregate finishes, for instance, are more susceptible to surface scaling due to freeze-thaw cycles.

Contractor, timing, and placement considerations

The concrete’s performance depends not just on its mix but also on how it’s placed and cured. Placement temperature is vital. Concrete should be placed at temperatures above freezing to prevent immediate freeze-thaw damage.

Curing practices are crucial too. Proper curing ensures the concrete gains strength uniformly, reducing the risk of cracking and improving resistance to freeze-thaw cycles.

Finishing practices matter as well. A smooth, dense surface finish reduces water absorption and improves durability in freeze-thaw conditions.

Work with your contractor to ensure they understand these factors. They should adjust their practices to match the chosen concrete type and local climate.

Back to top ↑

Air entrainment improves long-term freeze-thaw durability by creating a micro air-void system that reduces scaling and cracking, but it also affects workability, finishing time, and surface appearance if not controlled. The effective performance depends on matching air content targets with cement type, supplementary cementitious materials, aggregate grading, and admixture compatibility.

On-site controls should include confirming admixture dosing, monitoring slump and air readings at the plant and job, and adjusting finishing technique to account for entrainment. If results drift from targets, check mixing procedure, admixture compatibility, and environmental conditions, and require re-testing or corrective measures per the supplier instructions or lab recommendations.

Durability and lifespan impacts

Air-entrained concrete (AEC) improves long-term durability, especially in freeze-thaw environments. Here’s how:

Micro air void systems act like tiny shock absorbers, relieving pressure from freezing water. This reduces scaling, cracking propagation, and permeability.

Proper air content targets are crucial. They vary with cement type, supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs), and aggregate gradation. Too little air leaves concrete vulnerable; too much weakens it.

Regular quality control checks ensure your mix meets these targets. This maximizes durability and lifespan in harsh climates.

Workability and finishing effects

AEC changes workability, affecting pumpability, finishing time, shrinkage control, and surface quality. Here’s what to expect:

Air-entrained mixes often have lower slump. This can make pumping harder but improves finish quality by reducing segregation.

Finishing is easier with AEC due to reduced bleed. However, mismanaged air content can cause defects like honeycombing or laitance. Keep an eye on air content during placement.

To control shrinkage, use proper curing and consider shrinkage-reducing admixtures. This helps prevent cracking in drying conditions.

Strength and mix design trade-offs

Air reduces concrete’s unit weight, which can affect compressive strength. Here’s how to manage this:

To maintain desired strength, you might need to adjust cement content. More air means less space for cement and aggregates, so add more cement if needed.

Admixtures like superplasticizers can help too. They improve workability without sacrificing strength. But beware of adverse interactions with air-entraining agents.

Always check mix designs with your supplier. They can provide tailored advice based on your specific materials and climate conditions.

Back to top ↑

Lab methods (pressure meter, volumetric measurement) and field portable tests are used to verify air content; freeze-thaw durability testing may be run in specialized labs to confirm expected performance. Interpret results against the specified air-content target and note acceptable deviations stated by the project specification or supplier documentation.

On-site checks should include regular slump and air tests, temperature monitoring, quick visual checks for uniform voids and bleed behavior, and documented sampling cadence tied to each batch. Bring an air meter or portable tester, slump cone, sample containers, thermometers, curing materials, and recording sheets, and follow the equipment manufacturer’s calibration guidance and supplier testing protocol when readings fall outside targets.

Air-entrained mixes may incur added cost from air-entraining admixtures and possible changes in placement or finishing labor, while non-air-entrained mixes may save material cost upfront but risk more frequent repairs in freeze-thaw environments. Installation differences—pumpability, mixing tolerance, and winter protection needs—also affect short-term cost profiles.

Over the life of an exterior slab exposed to freezing and salts, air-entrained concrete typically reduces repair frequency and associated maintenance costs, but quantify that benefit against local climate, slab thickness, exposure, and planned maintenance. For budgeting, request lifecycle scenarios from suppliers or engineers and confirm assumptions about service life, repair intervals, and protection measures rather than relying on a single upfront cost figure.

Upfront cost differences

Air-entrained concrete comes at a higher initial cost due to the addition of air-entraining admixtures. These admixtures, usually around $2-$5 per cubic yard, create tiny bubbles in the mix that enhance durability.

Mix design adjustments may also increase costs. Air-entrained mixes often require more cement or fly ash to maintain strength, adding about $10-$30 per cubic yard.

Placement time might be slightly longer with air-entrained concrete due to its reduced slump and increased workability. This could add minor labor costs, but it’s usually offset by the improved finish quality.

Long-term maintenance and lifecycle trade-offs

Air-entrained concrete’s superior freeze-thaw resistance means fewer repairs and a longer service life. While the initial cost is higher, it can offset this over time.

Reduced repair frequency is the key benefit. Air-entrained mixes have better resistance to scaling and cracking from freeze-thaw cycles, reducing maintenance needs by up to 50%.

To calculate lifecycle costs, consider the expected service life of each mix (20-30 years for non-air-entrained vs 40+ years for air-entrained), repair/replacement frequency, and associated labor and material costs.

Frequent specification mistakes include wrong air-content targets, incorrect admixture dosages, and ignoring aggregate absorption or slump requirements—all of which can produce poor durability or finishing problems in cold weather. Winter sequencing mistakes such as inadequate curing, early-age freezing, or improper form removal can destroy an intended air-void system and create safety and performance issues.

Address safety by specifying proper PPE, chemical handling procedures, and site controls for cold-weather placing, and tailor ordering to local climate: specify air entrainment where freeze-thaw and salts are significant and note seasonal adjustments on the order. Confirm required tests and documentation on the batch ticket or product data sheet, and run the checklist before placing concrete to avoid rework and safety hazards.

Safety concerns during winter construction and mitigation steps

Winter construction with concrete poses unique safety risks. Mitigate these issues to keep your job site safe.

Early freeze: Concrete can be weakened if it freezes before gaining sufficient strength. Protect fresh concrete from freezing temperatures using blankets or heaters.

Weak surface and slipping hazards: Wet, weak surfaces can cause slips, trips, and falls. Keep surfaces clean and dry, and use non-slip materials where necessary. Ensure workers wear appropriate footwear.

Chemical exposure: Cold weather can increase the risk of skin irritation from concrete admixtures. Provide proper PPE and ensure workers understand its use and disposal.