Spalling Brick: Why Faces Pop Off and How to Stop Water Damage

Spalling means the brick face peels away from the body or flakes off in layers. It is different from simple surface flaking, which stays at the surface without opening up the brick. Look for signs that go beyond a cosmetic peel to deeper issues in the brick and mortar.

Moisture entry, freeze thaw cycles, and salt crystallization push outward on the brick face and can delaminate the coating. The result is a compromised surface that sheds weather tolerance and sheds water differently than intact brick. Expect hollow sounds, visible hollowness, and cracking near joints when the problem runs deeper than a superficial finish.

Freeze–thaw and thermal stresses

Spalling often starts when moisture gets trapped in tiny cracks or pores within the brick. When temperatures drop, this water expands as it freezes, pushing outward against the brick’s face.

This outward pressure can be powerful enough to break the fired clay face and accelerate flaking. The same happens in reverse when temperatures rise – heat causes expansion, further weakening the bond.

Over time, these freeze-thaw cycles and thermal stresses wear down the brick’s surface, making it more susceptible to spalling. It’s like a slow-motion chipping away at your walls.

Chemical salts, efflorescence, and corrosion

Salt crystals can form on the surface of bricks when water evaporates, leaving behind salt deposits. This is known as efflorescence. When temperatures fluctuate, these salts expand and contract, pushing at the brick face.

Corroding embedded metals, like rebar or wall ties, can also cause problems. As they rust, they expand and push against the brick, weakening its bond to the surface.

Salt-laden groundwater can exacerbate these issues. It’s not just about what you can see on the surface – it’s what’s happening inside your walls that matters.

Material and manufacturing causes

The materials used to make bricks, and how they’re fired, play a big role in spalling. Poor quality or underfired bricks are more likely to flake.

• Underfired/soft brick: These haven’t been heated enough during manufacturing. They’re weak and prone to cracking and staining. Look for ASTM C62 standards to ensure you’re getting properly fired bricks.
• Poor aggregates: Inconsistent or low-quality materials used in making the bricks can lead to weak spots that flake off over time. Check the spec sheet for consistent, high-quality aggregates.
• Porous facing: A porous surface lets water in, which leads to spalling. Look for dense, non-porous facings. Sealants can help here too.
• Improper storage: Bricks left exposed to the elements before use can absorb moisture and start the spalling process early. Keep bricks dry until you’re ready to lay them.
• Aging bricks: Over time, even high-quality bricks can degrade. Regular inspections help catch signs of aging before they become big problems.

Back to top ↑

Differentiate spalling from efflorescence, cracks, or mortar wear with clear visual cues and a tactile sense of looseness. Dry, powdery surfaces may be superficial, while hollow edges point to more serious issues.

High priority indicators include flaky surfaces, hollow or crumbly edges, and damp stains or salt crusts. Do a simple exterior walkaround, tap bricks gently to feel for looseness, and note whether several areas show a similar pattern. If interior signs of moisture appear, treat as urgent.

Moisture can enter through failed joints, cracked bricks, missing flashing, deteriorated lintels, or from capillary rise in porous masonry. Poor drainage around the wall also feeds moisture into the structure.

Surface sealing alone often fails because water remains behind joints, capillaries, or flashing. The wall must be dried and the source controlled before any finish work. Follow a practical field protocol to map how water travels from rooflines to the foundation.

Faulty mortar joints, cracks, and open head joints

Water loves to follow the path of least resistance. In your brick walls, that’s often through faulty or missing mortar.

Mortar is like the glue holding your bricks together. When it deteriorates or gets washed out, water can seep right into the brick body. This happens most at head joints—the horizontal joints where one course of bricks sits on top of another.

Check for: Crumbling mortar, missing chunks, or wide gaps between bricks. Use a screwdriver to probe suspect areas; if it goes in easily, you’ve got a problem.

Flashing, sills, and roof-to-wall details

Water can sneak into your walls where they meet the roof. This is usually due to poor installation or maintenance of flashing—the thin metal strips designed to direct water away from these vulnerable spots.

Sills are the horizontal pieces at the bottom of windows. If they’re damaged, water can leak behind them and into your walls. The same goes for any gaps around window openings.

Inspect: Flashing for rust or damage; sills for cracks or rot; and window openings for gaps. Look up from inside your home to see if light shines through any suspect areas.

Rising damp, groundwater, and landscape drainage

Water can also come from below. Groundwater can rise up through your walls—a process known as ‘rising damp.’ This happens when there’s no barrier to stop it, like a damp-proof course.

Poor site drainage can also cause persistent moisture problems. If water isn’t draining away from your foundation, it can build up and seep into your walls.

Check for: Water stains or efflorescence (white, powdery deposits) near the base of your walls. Look outside too; is water pooling around your foundation? Is your grading sloped away from the house?

Back to top ↑

Decide patch or replacement based on brick condition, depth of spalling, mortar integrity, and how many units are affected. Consider any load bearing or structural implications for the façade before choosing a path.

Outline an exterior survey, map damaged faces, photograph and measure areas, and document findings with a repeatable rubric. Distinguish cosmetic spalling from structural compromise to guide next steps. Plan for options like patching, tuckpointing, or partial rebuilds with a clear scope and schedule.

When face repair is appropriate

Face repairs are suitable when the brick’s core remains sound, and only the surface has been damaged. This could be due to minor spalling or efflorescence.

Check for: slight flaking, powdering, or minor exposed cores. Tap the bricks gently; they should sound solid.

Face repairs involve using color-matched repair mortars or consolidants to fill in the damaged areas. This method is quick and cost-effective but won’t address deeper issues.

When to replace bricks or rebuild sections

Replacing bricks or rebuilding sections becomes necessary when the damage affects the brick’s structural integrity. This could be due to severe spalling, cracks, or compromised mortar joints.

Look for: through-cracks (cracks that run all the way through the brick), severe loss of cross-section (more than 20% of the brick’s face is damaged), or bulging bricks indicating structural compromise.

Replacing individual units or rebuilding sections involves removing and replacing damaged bricks, often with matching reclaimed or new bricks. This method addresses deeper issues but can be more time-consuming and expensive.

When to involve an engineer or preservation specialist

Certain signs indicate that the damage is beyond a DIY repair and requires professional assessment. These include significant movement, bulging, or load-bearing failures.

Red flags: large cracks (over 1/4 inch wide), diagonal cracks, or bulging walls. If you notice any of these signs, stop work immediately and consult a structural engineer or preservation specialist.

Professionals have the tools and knowledge to assess the extent of the damage, determine the cause, and recommend appropriate repairs. They can also ensure that the repairs comply with building codes and historic preservation guidelines.

Back to top ↑

Four main options cover most jobs: face rebuilding, tuckpointing, individual brick replacement, and section rebuilds. Each has different labor, material needs, and durability outcomes suitable for specific situations.

Define DIY versus professional work by damage extent, structural concerns, access, and brick compatibility. Look for red flags that require a contractor, such as bowed walls or crumbling backing, and ensure proper curing and weather sealing for lasting repairs.

Brick face repair and repair mortar methods

When spalling occurs, the first step is to decide whether you’ll rebuild faces or just repoint. Rebuilding involves replacing entire sections of brickwork, while repointing focuses on fixing mortar joints.

Repair mortars are crucial here. They must match your existing mortar in color, texture, and permeability. Use a compatibility chart to ensure the right mix.

Applying repair mortars or surface rebuild materials is straightforward but requires patience. Scrub off loose material, dampen the area, apply mortar with a trowel, and tool it smooth. Let it cure properly for durability. Remember, these methods only work if the underlying structure is sound; otherwise, they’re just cosmetic.

Identify primary moisture sources and fix conditions that drive water into the wall rather than masking symptoms. Prioritize fixes that stop ingress at the source.

Exterior maintenance includes repointing with compatible mortar, repairing cracks, and ensuring flashing and gutters work. Keep drainage clear and direct downspouts away from the wall to protect the foundation.

Flashing, capillary breaks, and proper detailing

Properly installed flashing is your first line of defense against water intrusion. It diverts water away from the brick face and cavity.

Sills: Ensure they’re properly flashed with a wide, continuous piece of metal or membrane that extends over the outer edge of the sill. This prevents water from seeping behind the bricks.

Weep holes: These small openings at the bottom of walls allow trapped moisture to escape. Keep them clear and unobstructed to maintain proper drainage.

Drip details: Capillary breaks, like drip edges on sills or metal flashing at windows and doors, create a physical barrier that stops water from wicking up into the wall.

Breathable water-repellent treatments and when to use them

Silane/siloxane-type repellents work by filling microscopic pores in the brick, preventing water absorption without blocking vapor movement. They’re ideal for above-grade walls with no signs of moisture issues.

Before application: Check your bricks for any signs of dampness or efflorescence. These treatments won’t fix existing moisture problems; they prevent new ones.

Also, ensure there’s adequate vapor movement behind the wall. If water can’t escape, it may become trapped and cause further damage.

When not to use: Don’t apply these treatments to below-grade walls or areas with known moisture issues. They won’t fix rising damp or groundwater problems.

Color, texture, and mortar joints matter for seamless repairs and patch visibility. Strive for shade matching, finish, and joint profiles that blend with the surrounding brickwork.

Sourcing options include new bricks, salvaged bricks, and custom matches. Check grain, size tolerances, and warranty implications to guide when custom is needed and how it affects longevity.

Matching brick and mortar best practices

When repairing spalled bricks, seamless integration is key. Here’s how to match color, texture, and mortar for inconspicuous results.

Color: Bricks can vary in shade even within the same batch. To find a close match, compare potential replacement bricks under the same lighting conditions as your wall. Hold them next to each other at different angles to check for consistency.

Texture: Inspect the surface of your existing bricks. Some have a smooth face-slick finish, while others may be rough or have a wire-cut texture. Choose replacements that mimic this exactly.

Mortar: Matching mortar is just as important as matching bricks. The joint profile—width and shape—and the color of the mortar should mirror your existing joints. Use a sample from your wall to ensure an accurate match.

Sourcing options and implications for longevity

Three main sourcing options exist for replacement bricks, each with its pros, cons, lead times, and durability considerations.

New production: Buying new bricks from a manufacturer ensures consistency in size, shape, and color. However, they may not perfectly match older bricks due to changes in manufacturing processes over time. Warranties typically cover defects but not color matching.

Salvaged units: Reusing old bricks can provide an exact match, preserving the original look of your wall. However, sourcing enough salvaged bricks can be challenging and time-consuming. They may also have hidden damage or varying sizes that affect longevity.

Custom-manufactured faces: Custom bricks can provide a perfect match but come at a premium price. Lead times are often longer than standard production. Ensure the manufacturer understands your needs, provides samples, and offers a warranty covering color matching and durability.

Cost drivers and warranty expectations

The cost of brick repairs varies depending on several factors. Here’s what to expect and the warranties you should seek.

Extent of damage: The more bricks that need replacing, the higher the cost. Expect to pay around $10-$20 per brick, plus labor, scaffolding, disposal, and any related repairs like tuckpointing or repointing.

Access/height: Repairs requiring scaffolding or lifts will increase costs due to rental fees and safety measures. High-rise buildings may need specialized access equipment, further driving up prices.

Material rarity: Rare or specialty bricks can significantly increase repair costs. If your home has unique masonry, be prepared for higher-than-average expenses.

Warranty expectations: Reputable contractors should offer warranties on their workmanship and materials. Expect a warranty of at least one year covering labor and two years for materials. For custom bricks, insist on a color match guarantee from the manufacturer as well.

Back to top ↑

Safety comes first with proper PPE, fall protection, dust controls, and ladder or scaffold safety. Keep the site tidy and follow local permit requirements as needed.

Avoid common DIY mistakes that shorten repair life by ensuring proper mortar mix, addressing water management, and maintaining flashing and weep holes. Vet masonry contractors with experience, licenses, insurance, and solid references, and insist on a written scope and guarantees.

Access, fall protection, and dust/chemical safety

Working on brick repairs can expose you to various hazards. Here’s how to stay safe:

Fall Protection: Use ladders with secure footing or consider scaffolding for higher areas. Always maintain three points of contact.

Dust Control: Wear a respirator and safety glasses to protect against silica dust. Keep the work area clean and wet down surfaces to minimize dust.

Chemical Safety: Follow manufacturer guidelines when using repair chemicals. Wear gloves, long sleeves, and eye protection as needed.

How to evaluate and hire a masonry professional

Hiring the right contractor ensures quality workmanship. Here’s how to assess potential hires:

Licenses & Insurance: Verify they hold valid licenses and carry adequate insurance coverage.

Past Projects: Ask for photos of similar brick repair jobs they’ve completed. This helps you gauge their skill and expertise.

Material Specs & Bids: Request material specifications and written bids from at least three contractors. Compare these to make an informed decision.

Back to top ↑