Shingle Vs Tile Roof – Pick by Use Case

Shingles are typically asphalt or composite, while tiles are clay, concrete, or ceramic. Weight, installation needs, and common subtypes differ in how they’re supported and installed on a roof.

Lifespan and durability vary with climate and maintenance, and cost profiles reflect material and labor over time. Roof form, attic space, and ventilation influence which option fits best, along with curb appeal and neighborhood standards.

What shingles are (types & features)

Shingles are a popular choice for roofing due to their affordability and ease of installation. They’re typically made from asphalt or fiberglass.

Asphalt shingles are the most common. They come in two main styles:

• 3-tab: These are basic, flat shingles with a simple design and a 20-30 year lifespan.
• Architectural: Also known as dimensional or laminate shingles, they have a layered look and last longer (up to 50 years).

Fiberglass shingles are more durable and fire-resistant. They’re usually architectural-style.

Short-term cost tends to be lower for shingles, with material and installation often cheaper than tile options. This can translate to quicker project starts and smaller upfront commitments.

Installation is typically fast, and there’s broad contractor availability. Shingles offer wide design and color variety to boost curb appeal affordably.

Cost and installation benefits

Asphalt shingles are the most affordable roofing material upfront. Expect to pay around $100 – $200 per square (100 sq ft). That’s about half the cost of tile or metal roofs.

The labor costs are also lower due to simpler installation. Most contractors charge between $350 – $600 per square for labor, making shingle installs around 30% cheaper than tiles.

Shingles go on fast too. A crew can install 100 sq ft in a day or two, depending on the roof’s complexity. This speed helps keep project timelines short and labor costs down.

Tip: Shingle installs are less weather-dependent than tiles. They can be installed in temperatures as low as 20°F (-7°C), making them a good choice for colder regions with shorter installation windows.

Design flexibility and replacement ease

Shingles come in various styles – from traditional three-tab to architectural, which mimic the look of slate or wood. They also offer a wide range of colors to match your home’s aesthetic.

The interlocking design makes shingles easy to repair or replace. If a few shingles get damaged, you can simply remove and replace them without affecting the rest of the roof. This isn’t possible with tiles, which often require partial re-roofing.

Shingles also allow for phased replacements. If your budget doesn’t cover the entire roof at once, you can do one section at a time without compromising the integrity of the whole system.

Note: While shingles offer great flexibility, they may not be suitable for roofs with pitches below 4/12 due to their interlocking design.

Back to top ↑

Service life for shingles varies and is generally shorter than tile in harsh climates, with climate and roof orientation affecting longevity. Expect more frequent maintenance and potential replacement cycles.

Weather vulnerabilities include wind uplift, hail impact, and granule loss, which drive ongoing upkeep. Consider how local conditions influence roof performance and DIY feasibility.

Durability limits and maintenance needs

Shingle roofs typically last between 15 to 25 years, depending on the quality of materials and local conditions. Lower-quality shingles may only last a decade or less.

Signs of failure include curling edges, cupping in the middle, and granule loss. Regular inspections can help catch these issues early. Flashings around chimneys, vents, and skylights should be checked annually for leaks.

Maintenance tasks include keeping gutters clear of leaves, preventing moss and algae buildup with periodic cleaning or treatment, and resealing any exposed nail heads to prevent water intrusion. Expect to spend a few hundred dollars every 5-7 years on maintenance.

Performance in extreme climates

High-heat regions can shorten shingle lifespan due to UV degradation. Shingles may become brittle and crack, leading to leaks. In such areas, consider algae-resistant or cooling shingles.

High-wind areas pose a risk of wind uplift, especially on lower-pitched roofs. Shingles may peel off, leaving the roof vulnerable. Ensure your shingles meet local wind resistance standards and consider using additional fasteners if needed.

Hail-prone regions can cause significant damage to shingles, leading to granule loss and leaks. Impact-resistant shingles are an option for these areas, but they come at a higher cost. Always check your insurance policy regarding hail damage coverage.

Back to top ↑

Tile roofs offer long lifespans and durable performance, often surpassing shingles in many climates. Substrates, climate, and maintenance influence how long tiles last and when replacements may be needed.

They provide strong fire resistance, distinctive aesthetics, and robust wind uplift performance. The architectural look and color options can elevate curb appeal in many home styles.

Longevity, durability, and safety

Tile roofs are built to last. With proper installation, you’re looking at 50+ years of service. That’s more than double the lifespan of shingles.

Climate and maintenance play a role in longevity. In harsh climates like ours, tiles hold up better due to their resistance to rot, UV damage, and fire. They won’t curl or crack like shingles under extreme heat or cold.

Proper installation is key for safety too. Tiles are heavy, so they stay put in high winds. With the right underlayment and fasteners, a tile roof can withstand wind uplift better than most other materials.

Aesthetics and energy performance

Tile roofs add instant curb appeal. With various colors, profiles, and textures, they complement any architectural style. From classic red to modern terracotta, you’ve got options.

Tiles’ thermal mass can help regulate attic temperatures. They absorb heat during the day and release it at night, keeping your home cooler in summer. Some tiles even come with reflective coatings for extra cooling power.

Maintenance is minimal but not zero. Occasional cleaning might be needed to keep moss or dirt from building up. But compared to shingles’ regular repairs, that’s a small price to pay.

Back to top ↑

Upfront costs are higher for tile roofs, reflecting materials, labor, and installation complexity. Budget planning should account for longer project timelines and potential extra expenses.

Structural load is substantial, often requiring a professional assessment and possible retrofits. Installation and future repairs are more specialized and may limit DIY feasibility.

Structural requirements and installation complexity

Tile roofs are heavy. Before you start, get a professional to check your roof’s structure. They’ll tell you if it needs reinforcing or retrofitting – that could mean extra costs for joists or framing.

Expect added costs: Reinforcement can run $200-$500 per joist. It’s worth it, though, to avoid costly repairs later on.

Tile installation is tricky. You need experienced pros who know how to lay them right. They’ll ensure your tiles are aligned properly and won’t crack under pressure. Don’t skimp: Hire good installers or you might end up with leaks, misaligned tiles, or worse.

Cost trade-offs and repair considerations

Tile roofs cost more upfront. But they last longer than shingles, so you might save in the long run. Just remember, budget for maintenance: Tiles need care to keep them looking good.

Repairing tiles isn’t like fixing shingles. You can’t just patch a spot. Often, you’ll have to replace whole tiles. That’s more work and more cost. But it keeps your roof looking neat.

Hidden expenses: Underlayment and specialty flashings can add to the bill. Make sure you factor those in when planning your budget. And don’t forget about maintenance – cleaning, inspecting, and replacing tiles as needed.

Back to top ↑

Total cost of ownership compares upfront costs, maintenance, energy impacts, and potential resale value over the roof’s life. Check your local conditions and expected life when estimating TCO.

Consider replacement cycles, warranty terms, and how a roof choice affects different property types. Gather local pricing, typical installation times, and maintenance costs to ground your numbers.

Total cost of ownership (TCO) factors

The total cost of owning a roof is more than just the upfront price. Here are key factors to consider:

Initial Purchase & Installation: Shingles are cheaper, around $100-$200 per square (100 sq ft), while tiles range from $300-$800.

Maintenance: Shingles need more frequent maintenance and repairs. Tiles last longer but may require professional cleaning or repair.

Insurance & Energy Savings: Some insurers offer discounts for tile roofs due to their durability. Both can save on energy bills, with tiles offering better insulation.

Use-case scenarios and sample recommendations

Different situations call for different roofing choices:

Short-term Ownership: If you plan to sell soon, shingles are a better investment due to their lower upfront cost.

Coastal/High-wind Areas: Tiles hold up better in high winds and salt corrosion. Consider Class 4 impact-resistant tiles for hail-prone regions.

Historic/Architectural Homes: Tiles often fit the aesthetic better, but check structural integrity can support their weight.

Hot Climates: Both work well in heat, but tiles reflect more sun rays, keeping homes cooler. Consider light-colored options for best results.

Back to top ↑

Compare embodied energy and raw materials for shingles versus tiles, and look at end-of-life options. Production, transport, and disposal all play a role in sustainability.

Recyclability and long-term waste are relevant, as is cooling and heating impact on indoor comfort. Practical options like cool shingles or reflective coatings can influence performance and costs over time.

Sustainability metrics to check

When comparing shingles and tiles, look for these sustainability specs:

Recycled Content: Aim for at least 20% recycled material. Some products go up to 95%.

Recyclability: Check if the product can be recycled at end-of-life. Some manufacturers offer take-back programs.

Solar Reflectance Index (SRI): Look for values above 78 for cool roof options, which reflect more sunlight and reduce heat gain.

Cool roof and energy-saving opportunities

Cool roofs can save you money on cooling costs. Here’s how:

Light-colored or white shingles and tiles reflect more sunlight, reducing heat gain compared to dark ones.

Reflective coatings can be applied to both shingles and tiles, boosting their solar reflectance. Some even come pre-applied.

In hot climates, cool roofs can reduce indoor temperatures by up to 10°F (5.6°C), making them a smart choice for energy efficiency. But remember, they might not be as effective in cold climates due to reduced thermal mass.

Back to top ↑

Local building codes, fire ratings, and wind-resistance rules affect material choices and permit needs. Check triggers for inspections and any design review milestones early in the planning.

Historic district rules, HOA covenants, and architectural guidelines can restrict color and material options. Gather product specs, fire ratings, warranty documents, and permit packages to keep approvals moving smoothly.

Permits, fire ratings, and wind classifications

Before you start any roofing project, understand the local regulations. These can impact your choice of shingle or tile.

Fire Ratings: Check for minimum fire resistance and ignition resistance ratings (Class A/B). Roofs must meet these standards. Concrete tiles usually have better fire ratings than asphalt shingles.

Wind Uplift Classes: Your roof needs to withstand local wind speeds. Ask manufacturers/contractors for wind uplift classes. This is crucial in areas prone to high winds or hurricanes.

HOA and historic district issues

If you live in an HOA community or a historic district, there are extra steps to take.

HOA Approval: Check your HOA covenants. They might dictate roofing materials, colors, or warranties. You may need board approval or design review before starting work.

Historic District Rules: If you’re in a historic district, there are likely design guidelines and approved color palettes. Stick to these to avoid noncompliance or required approvals. Historic districts often prefer tiles over shingles for their durability and aesthetic appeal.

Back to top ↑