Roof Decking Replacement – DIY Steps + Stop Points

Decking decisions hinge on safety, rot, and overall moisture history. Look for soft spots, widespread warping, and signs of progressive decay. Sagging framing or repeated leaks point toward replacement rather than patching.

Use objective checks like the condition of the plywood or OSB and the integrity of fasteners to gauge urgency. Verify with product labels, manufacturer instructions, or local building rules if you’re uncertain. If there is uncertain moisture history, consider a cautious approach and consult a pro for a formal assessment.

Under-Roof Issues That Force Replacement

Sometimes, the problems aren’t visible from the top. Here are some hidden causes that might require a full decking replacement.

Prolonged leaks: If water has been leaking for a long time, it can cause extensive rot and damage to the rafters underneath. This is a safety hazard and needs immediate attention.

Mold and mildew: If you see or smell mold under your roof, it’s a sign of excessive moisture. Mold can weaken the structure and pose health risks.

Insect damage: Termites, carpenter ants, and other insects can cause significant damage to your roof decking. If you suspect insect activity, have it checked out immediately.

Compromised rafters: If the rafters underneath are damaged or rotted, they won’t support a new layer of decking. In this case, replacement is necessary.

When a Contractor Should Be Called Immediately

Some roof issues are too serious or unsafe for DIY repairs. Here are some red flags that require professional assessment and emergency measures.

Structural sag: If your roof is sagging, it’s a sign of severe damage to the rafters underneath. This is a safety hazard and needs immediate attention from a professional.

Large rot areas: If you find large areas of rot, it’s best to call in a pro. They have the tools and knowledge to assess the extent of the damage and make necessary repairs or replacements.

Active leaks causing interior damage: If water is leaking into your home, it can cause extensive damage to your walls, ceilings, and personal belongings. This requires immediate action from a professional roofer.

Back to top ↑

List essential items first: a solid ladder, PPE, pry bars, autility knife, and a circular saw or handsaw for decking. Add a drill with bits and a nail puller for fasteners. Include a pry bar, chalk line, and square for layout checks.

Optional but helpful items: a magnetic pry tool, cordless multi-tool, and a nailing ruler for consistent spacing. Safety gear such as gloves, eye protection, and a harness or fall-arrest system should be included. Always double-check the manufacturer instructions for any specific tool requirements.

Personal protective equipment and fall protection

Safety first. Here’s what you need to protect yourself from falls and injuries.

Back to top ↑

Secure the work area with barriers or signage as needed to keep pets and curious neighbors out. Protect landscaping, siding, and interiors from debris with tarps and edge protection. Plan safe access and establish fall protection before removing any decking.

Coordinate with neighbors if dust or noise could affect them and contact utility companies if any lines are nearby. Follow local rules for permits or inspections as required. Always have a clear plan for weather changes and emergency steps.

Temporary Roof Covering and Weather Planning

Before you start tearing off the old decking, plan for weather. Rain can cause serious damage to your home’s interior.

Use tarps to cover the area. Secure them tightly with ropes or weights. Make sure they overlap enough to keep water out.

Schedule your work around forecasted rain. It’s better to wait a day than risk damaging your home.

Scaffolding, Ladder Use, and Site Barriers

Safety starts with stable access. Set up scaffolding or a sturdy ladder. Make sure it’s secure and level.

Use barriers to keep bystanders and pets away from the work zone. This could be cones, tape, or even a makeshift fence.

If you’re using a ladder, make sure it extends at least 3 feet above the roof edge. Secure it every 10 feet with a tie-off.

Electrical, Ventilation, and Utility Checks

Before you start working, check for any electrical fixtures on the roof. You don’t want to accidentally damage them or cause a short.

If there are vents or chimneys, make sure they’re protected. You might need to temporarily relocate them if they’re in your way.

Also, check for any utility lines. They could be damaged during work. If you’re unsure, contact your utility company for help.

Back to top ↑

Begin by removing shingles or roofing material to expose the decking edge. Work from the top down, carefully prying up the underlayment without tearing the roof structure. Remove nails and fasteners as you go to minimize damage.

Pattern your removal to keep the underlying framing intact, nudging decking boards free without splintering nearby edges. Keep debris organized for easy re-use or disposal. If you encounter compromised framing, halt and reassess the scope before continuing.

Shingle and Underlayment Removal Technique

Removing shingles and underlayment safely is key to preserving your roof’s structure. Here’s how to do it right.

Start at the peak, working down in rows. Use a flat pry bar or cat’s paw tool to lift each shingle up, then slide it off. Be careful not to damage the roof deck underneath.

Once all shingles are removed, you’ll see the underlayment. If it’s in good condition, carefully peel it off in large sheets. If it’s damaged or stuck, use a utility knife to cut it into manageable pieces before removing.

Never walk on the roof deck without proper footwear and caution. Wear soft-soled shoes to avoid damaging the decking, and watch your step to prevent falls.

Removing Damaged Decking and Assessing Framing

Now that you’ve removed the shingles and underlayment, it’s time to assess and remove any damaged decking.

Use a circular saw with a deep-cut blade to cut out bad sections of decking. Make your cuts along the rafters or joists for minimal damage. If you’re unsure about cutting, consult a professional before proceeding.

Once you’ve removed the damaged decking, inspect the rafters and joists underneath. Look for signs of rot, warping, or other structural issues. If you find any, stop work immediately and call a professional contractor.

Stop Point A: After Old Decking Removed

Before installing new decking, it’s crucial to inspect your roof structure and ensure everything is in good condition. Here are the tasks you must complete at this stop point.

First, check the rafters and joists for any signs of rot or damage. If necessary, use a moisture meter to test for excess moisture, which could indicate hidden leaks or water damage.

Next, inspect your roof’s ventilation. Ensure there are no obstructions in your soffit vents or ridge vent, and that they’re functioning properly. Good ventilation is key to preventing future issues with your new decking.

Back to top ↑

Choose board orientation that suits the roof layout and ventilation needs, and plan starting edges accordingly. Space boards consistently to allow for drainage and expansion. Stagger seams to reduce weak points and follow a logical pattern across the deck surface.

Adopt a fastening pattern that matches your decking material and local guidance. Avoid common mistakes like over-tightening or driving nails too close to board edges. Verify fastening depth and alignment with the manufacturer instructions or local code references as needed.

Measuring, cutting, and fitting sheets

Start by laying out your plywood or OSB sheets on the roof. Make sure to stagger seams for strength.

Cut around any chimneys or vents using a circular saw with a fine-tooth blade. Ensure you have at least 2 inches of decking on each side of these openings.

For edge support, use blocking between joists and the first row of decking. This helps distribute weight evenly and prevents sagging.

Fastening schedule and nail/screw selection

Use 8d or 10d galvanized nails, or 2-inch screws for fastening. Nails are faster but screws provide better holding power.

Space fasteners every 6 inches along the joists and every 8-10 inches along the field of the decking. Always check local building codes for specific requirements.

Use a nail gun or drill/screw gun to drive fasteners flush with the surface, but be careful not to overdrive them into the roof structure.

Stop Point B: Structural and fastening inspection

Before moving on to the next step, it’s crucial to inspect your work. This helps catch any issues early.

Back to top ↑

Reinstall or replace roof vents and ensure vent pathways are clear and properly seated. Inspect and renew flashing where needed to direct water away from joints. Seal all penetrations to prevent leaks and maintain ventilation paths.

Align flashing with the new decking and ensure transitions are smooth across joints. Verify that any flashing materials meet manufacturer instructions and local code requirements. Double-check clearance around vents and chimneys before finishing.

Proper flashing installation around chimneys and skylights

Flashing is your first line of defense against water intrusion. Here’s how to install it right:

Chimneys: Use step flashing, base flashing, and counter flashing. Install step flashing up the sides of the chimney, overlapping each piece. Place base flashing at the bottom, lapping under the shingles. Secure counter flashing over the step flashing, bending it around the chimney.

Skylights: Use a combination of step and pan flashings. Install step flashing as with chimneys. For pans, place them under the skylight’s base, ensuring they’re sloped to direct water away from the opening. Seal all seams with roofing cement.

Re-establishing ridge, soffit, and eave ventilation

Maintaining proper airflow prevents moisture buildup. Here’s how to ensure your roof breathes:

Ridge vents: Install them along the peak of your roof. Ensure they’re well-sealed but allow for airflow. If you’ve added insulation that blocks intake vents, install baffles at the eaves.

Soffit and eave vents: These provide intake air. Make sure they’re not blocked by insulation or other obstacles. If necessary, add more vents to maintain a balanced system (equal intake and exhaust).

Stop Point C: Water-tightness verification

Before laying underlayment, check your work for leaks. Here’s how:

Inspect all flashings and penetrations. Look for any gaps or cracks. Use a garden hose to simulate rain, checking for leaks around chimneys, skylights, and vents.

If you find any issues, address them immediately. If you’re unsure, don’t hesitate to call a professional roofer. It’s better to be safe than sorry when it comes to your roof.

Back to top ↑

Select underlayment layers that suit your climate and roof setup, and place them in the correct order. Place ice and water shield in vulnerable areas per instructions, ensuring proper overlap and coverage. Apply starter strips to create a solid base for shingles and consistent edge alignment.

Follow the installation order for all layers and verify that overlaps and fasteners meet the product labeling. Do not skip required treatments in valleys or eaves; consult the label if you’re unsure. If in doubt, compare against manufacturer guidance or local building rules before proceeding.

Choosing the right underlayment for your climate

The first step in protecting your roof is choosing the right underlayment. You’ve got two main options: synthetic and felt.

Synthetic: These are more durable, tear-resistant, and can last longer than felt. They’re great for all climates but shine in hotter regions where they won’t degrade as quickly.

Felt: Felt underlayment is cheaper but less durable. It’s fine for cooler climates, but it degrades faster in heat and can absorb moisture, leading to mold or mildew growth.

Now, where does the ice/water shield come in? You’ll want that in vulnerable areas like eaves, valleys, and roof-to-wall transitions. It provides an extra layer of protection against water intrusion.

Installation best practices and overlap methods

Once you’ve picked your underlayment, it’s time to install. Start from the bottom up, working your way towards the ridge.

Overlaps: Overlap each sheet by at least 4 inches. For ice/water shield, overlap by 6 inches in vulnerable areas. This ensures no water can sneak through.

Fastener placement: Drive fasteners every 6-8 inches along the seams and edges. Keep them within 1 inch of the edge but not too close to avoid splitting the underlayment.

Keep your underlayment flat and wrinkle-free. Wrinkles can trap water, leading to leaks. If you’re working in windy conditions, consider using temporary fasteners to keep it secure until you can fully install it.

Stop Point D: Final pre-shingle inspection

Before you start slapping on those shingles, it’s time for a final check. This ensures your underlayment is doing its job and there are no surprises hiding underneath.

Back to top ↑