Steel Trowel vs Magnesium Float: Which Finish Fits Which Job

Use this as a quick decision aid before diving into the details. It helps you decide when to reach for a steel trowel versus a magnesium float based on the project type and the surface you want.

You’ll notice visual cues too: a steel trowel finish tends to be tighter and glassy, while a magnesium float yields a more matte, open texture with fewer swirl marks. Timing and set considerations also matter, since cure speed and surface moisture affect your best approach.

Quick decision criteria

Choosing between a steel trowel and magnesium float depends on your project’s needs. Here are quick, no-nonsense guidelines.

For smooth, hard surfaces: Reach for the steel trowel. It’s ideal for floors with heavy traffic like garages or workshops. It leaves a tight, glassy finish.

For more textured, less shiny surfaces: Opt for the magnesium float. It’s great for driveways, patios, or overlays where you want a more natural look with fewer swirl marks.

This defines a dense, smooth surface created by hand or power troweling with steel blades. It contrasts with mag float or broom finishes in texture and sheen.

Hand versus power troweling changes the finish quality and application method. Both have their place for interior or exposed applications, depending on visibility and wear expectations.

How a steel trowel finish is produced

A steel trowel finish is achieved by using a steel trowel tool to smooth and densify the concrete surface. The key steps involve:

1. Timing: Wait until the concrete has set enough to support your weight, usually around 4-8 hours after pouring.

2. Technique: Hold the trowel flat against the surface and use a sweeping motion to spread and level the concrete paste. Work from the middle of the slab towards the edges, overlapping each pass slightly.

3. Consistency: Maintain even pressure on the trowel and keep your passes consistent to avoid leaving marks or uneven spots.

Typical outcomes and where it’s best used

A well-executed steel trowel finish results in a smooth, dense surface with a slight sheen. The slip resistance is moderate to high, making it suitable for various applications:

Interior Floors: Steel trowel finishes are ideal for interior concrete floors due to their durability and ease of cleaning.

Polished Surfaces: The smooth surface created by steel troweling makes it an excellent base for polished or sealed decorative surfaces.

Exposed Applications: In outdoor or exposed areas, a steel trowel finish can provide a durable, low-maintenance surface that’s resistant to weathering and wear.

Back to top ↑

A magnesium float finish produces a textured, consolidated surface that is often preferred for exterior slabs and non-slip areas. The float leaves a distinctive, closed texture compared with steel trowel finishes.

Understanding pressing, dragging, and circular passes helps you plan when to start and stop floating based on set and bleed. This finish supports traction and outdoor durability when used correctly.

How a Magnesium Float Finish Is Produced

A magnesium float finish is created by using a magnesium float tool, which has a flat, smooth surface with rounded edges. The float is pressed and dragged across the concrete surface in circular or overlapping passes.

The float’s motion consolidates the concrete, pushing excess water (bleed) to the surface while leveling and texturizing it. This creates a closed, non-porous surface that resists water absorption.

Timing is crucial. Floating should start when the concrete has set enough to support the float without leaving footprints but before it becomes too hard. Typically, this is around 30-50% of final set.

After floating, you may need to follow up with additional finishing steps, such as brooming or brushing, depending on your desired finish and project requirements.

Typical Outcomes and Where It’s Best Used

A magnesium float finish results in a textured surface with a low sheen. The texture is created by the float’s motion, which leaves small ridges and valleys, providing excellent traction.

This finish is ideal for exterior slabs, ramps, sidewalks, pool decks, and other areas where slip resistance and durability are crucial. It helps prevent water from pooling on the surface, reducing the risk of ice buildup in colder climates.

Compared to a steel trowel finish, which has a smooth, glossy appearance, a magnesium float finish offers better traction but less sheen. It’s often preferred for outdoor areas where aesthetics are secondary to functionality and safety.

However, it may not be suitable for indoor floors or areas where a smooth, seamless look is desired. Always consider your project’s specific needs when choosing a finish.

Back to top ↑

This section covers practical tool categories you’ll rely on, including hand tools like trowels, floats, edgers, and their handles. It also references power equipment and common replacement blades or plates and their compatibility notes.

Then you’ll see consumables and wear items, plus indicators that items need replacement due to wear or contamination. Look for variant selection factors that influence tool choice and blade/plate type without listing specific part numbers.

Key material properties to consider are wear resistance, hardness, corrosion resistance, and fatigue life. These influence finish quality and tool longevity when selecting blades and plates.

Compare common materials and their typical use cases, including pros and cons for different concrete mixes and environments. Also, note thicknesses, edge profiles, mounting hardware, and how these affect performance and vibration transfer.

Industry standards and certifications

Certifications ensure your tools meet safety and performance standards. Here are a few to look for:

ASTM International (formerly American Society for Testing and Materials): Their standards cover everything from tool materials to finish quality.

For trowels, look for ASTM C781. For floats, it’s ASTM C506. These ensure your tools are up to snuff.

ISO (International Organization for Standardization): Similar to ASTM, ISO sets global standards. Check for ISO 1922-1 and ISO 1923 for trowels and floats respectively.

Back to top ↑

Outline the core workflows for floating and troweling, and indicate when to choose magnesium float versus steel trowel. Expect a progression from initial float to final passes without hard timing data.

Include starter, intermediate, and finish sequences, plus pre-wet versus dry edge techniques. Mention practical criteria for tool setup and how these choices affect texture and edge containment.

Hand techniques and pressure control

Mastering hand techniques is crucial for a professional finish. Here’s how to handle steel trowels and magnesium floats:

Steel Trowel: Hold the handle at a 45-degree angle, apply light pressure, and use smooth, continuous strokes. For sheen development, increase pressure slightly and reduce stroke width.

Magnesium Float: Hold the float vertically for initial passes to distribute material evenly. As the slab sets, tilt the float to around a 45-degree angle to remove excess water and level the surface.

Pressure control is key: too much pressure can overwork the slab, while too little won’t achieve the desired finish. Practice makes perfect – start with light pressure and adjust as needed.

Using power equipment vs hand tools

Power trowels and floats can speed up the process, but they require careful control to avoid damaging the slab.

• Lightweight Power Trowel: Use when slab is firm enough (around 6-8 hours post-pour) for sheen development. Maintain consistent speed (around 120-150 RPM) and keep blades off edges to prevent gouging.
• Power Float: Ideal for large surfaces or where time is a factor. Use when bleed water is still present, applying even pressure across the slab’s surface.
• Darby Boards (Manual/Electric): Great for edging and finishing small areas. Apply light pressure, keep blades off edges, and maintain consistent speed to avoid overworking or underworking.
• Rentable Tools: Consider renting power tools if you don’t have the budget to buy. Prices vary by region but expect to pay around $50-$100 per day for a lightweight power trowel, and $30-$60 for darby boards.

Environmental and mix considerations during application

Temperature, wind, and mix consistency can impact your finishing choices. Here’s what to watch for:

Temperature: Warmer temperatures speed up curing time. Adjust your finishing schedule accordingly – more passes may be needed in cooler conditions.

Wind: Strong winds can cause rapid evaporation of bleed water, leading to a rough surface. Use windbreaks or perform initial floats when wind is minimal.

Mix Consistency: A well-mixed concrete ensures an even finish. Check the mix at the pour – if it’s lumpy or inconsistent, consider remixing before application.

Back to top ↑

Define performance metrics and finish outcomes to compare, including how each tool affects initial float, bleed control, sheen, and potential gouging. Clarify which finishes each tool best supports.

Discuss durability and maintenance, including wear, sharpening needs, cleaning routines, and storage considerations. Consider how exposure and chemicals impact long-term usability when planning replacement or reconditioning.

Durability and upkeep

Steel trowels and magnesium floats both wear over time, but they do so differently.

Steel trowels can rust if not properly cared for. Rust weakens the blade edge, leading to chipping or breaking. To extend their life, clean and dry them after each use, store in a cool, dry place, and sharpen as needed.

Magnesium floats are less prone to wear but can chip under heavy use or improper storage. Keep them clean and dry, avoid excessive pressure when floating, and replace any chipped plates promptly.

Cost drivers and lifecycle thinking

The initial purchase price is just the start of your tool’s cost. Long-term value depends on durability, maintenance needs, and labor time.

Steel trowels are cheaper to buy but require more frequent sharpening or replacement due to rust. They also need regular cleaning and proper storage to prevent damage.

Magnesium floats cost more upfront but last longer with minimal maintenance. However, their plates can’t be resharpened once chipped, so you’ll need to replace them.

Consider your project’s scale and budget when choosing between steel trowels and magnesium floats. For small residential jobs, the lower initial cost of steel might be preferable. But for larger commercial projects, the longer lifespan of magnesium could save money in the long run.

How finish affects maintenance of the concrete surface

The type of finish you choose with your trowel or float impacts how much upkeep your concrete needs.

A trowelled finish, achieved with a steel trowel, requires minimal maintenance. Just sweep and hose down to remove dirt. However, it’s less resistant to cracking and may need occasional repairs.

A burnished or brushed finish, created using a magnesium float, needs more care. Dirt can embed in the textured surface, requiring regular cleaning with a pressure washer. But these finishes are more crack-resistant and hide imperfections better.

For exterior pours or high-traffic floors, consider the finish’s durability and maintenance requirements. A trowelled finish might be best for low-traffic areas, while a burnished or brushed finish could be ideal for heavy use or outdoor exposure.

Back to top ↑

Cover tool selection and timing, such as when to use steel trowels versus magnesium floats and how surface moisture influences grip and burnisher needs. Plan to minimize rework with a clear finish plan.

Highlight safety basics like PPE and proper lifting techniques, plus safety around power trowels. Include planning steps to catch issues early and maintain a reliable prefinish checklist.

Safety tips and required PPE

Your safety and your crew’s are paramount. Here are some essential safety practices:

PPE: Wear gloves, eye protection, and non-slip footwear to prevent injuries.

Be aware of concrete dust, it can cause respiratory issues. Wet down surfaces before working to minimize dust.

When using power trowels, follow manufacturer’s guidelines for safe operation. Be mindful of wiring and keep the area clear of debris.