Lime Putty vs Hydrated Lime for Plaster: A Timeline Comparison

Lime putty is a water-saturated, doughy form of calcium hydroxide produced by slaking quicklime with plenty of water and ageing; hydrated lime is typically supplied as a dry powder made by controlled slaking and drying. Each is used in plaster systems but behaves differently on the trowel and during curing, so pick based on the job’s need for plasticity or faster, predictable mixes.

Putty often comes in tubs or tubs from suppliers and is bought by volume or aged batches, while hydrated lime arrives in bags or pre-blended products and is measured by weight; check the product label or data sheet for the supplied format. Expect putty to give longer open time and more plasticity, and hydrated lime to rehydrate and stiffen quicker—consider substrate type, exposure, and whether traditional breathability or faster turnaround is the priority.

What is lime putty

Lime putty, also known as ‘fat lime’, is a traditional plastering material made by slaking quicklime with water. It’s called ‘putty’ because it has a creamy, spreadable consistency similar to putty.

It feels cool to the touch and has a natural plasticity that makes it easy to work with. This is why craftsmen favor it for traditional plastering techniques like limewashing and rendering.

Key point: Lime putty takes time to mature, gaining strength over weeks or months.

What is hydrated lime (dry hydrated/super-hydrated)

Hydrated lime, also called ‘air lime’, is made by grinding limestone and then adding water to start the hydration process. It’s sold in dry powder form.

It has a fine texture that’s easy to mix with sand for plastering. Unlike lime putty, it doesn’t need time to mature before use. You can buy it as ‘dry hydrated’ or ‘super-hydrated’, which means the hydration process is already underway.

Key point: Hydrated lime sets quickly and provides early strength.

Lime putty exists as a wet, colloidal slurry with larger flocs and retained water; hydrated lime is a dry powder of finer particles that must rehydrate in the mix. Those physical forms control how much water the mix takes, how long the plaster stays workable, and how the material bonds to sand and fibres—consult the manufacturer’s technical notes when in doubt about reactivity or suggested mix practices.

Particle fineness and surface area affect water demand and slump: coarser flocculated putty behaves differently than fine powdered hydrated lime, which can demand more mixing effort to reach a uniform blend. Reactivity and curing dynamics differ too—putty relies on gradual carbonation and longer plasticity, while hydrated lime gives a more immediate chemical response—so monitor ambient temperature and substrate moisture as they will change workability and shrinkage behavior.

Consistency, particle size and shelf life

Lime putty is a thick, creamy paste due to its high water content. Hydrated lime, on the other hand, is a fine powder that needs rehydration before use.

Shelf Life: Lime putty’s water content allows it to age well, retaining workability for months if stored properly. Hydrated lime has a shorter shelf life once opened due to its reactivity with air moisture.

Particle size matters too. Larger lumps in hydrated lime can lead to inconsistent mixing and slump issues. Lime putty’s smaller, uniform particles ensure better blending and easier application.

Reactivity, pH and carbonation behavior

Lime putty gains strength primarily through carbonation – a slow reaction with CO2 in the air. This makes it less reactive initially but stronger long-term.

Hydrated lime reacts quickly with water during mixing (hydration) and then sets rapidly due to its high initial reactivity. However, this quick set can lead to reduced long-term strength if not managed properly.

pH: Both are highly alkaline (pH around 12), but hydrated lime’s higher initial pH can cause more rapid curing and potential issues with substrate compatibility.

Lime putty’s slower, more gradual carbonation allows it to maintain plasticity longer, reducing drying shrinkage and improving long-term performance.

Back to top ↑

Putty mixes typically give a creamy, tacky feel with long open time and forgiving finishing; hydrated lime mixes can firm up faster and feel less sticky, altering trowelling technique. Adjust water, sand grading, and mixing times on-site and always try a small batch so you can gauge drag and slip before committing to large areas.

Batch variability and ambient conditions—hot sun or damp mornings—affect slump, absorption, and early set, so perform an on-site open-time test and a small trowel trial to check feathering and pinholes. If adhesion or cure looks off, stop and refer to the product sheet or make a test patch with adjusted water, aggregate, or a compatible pozzolan before continuing.

Plasticity, Open Time and Finishability

When it comes to plastering, you want a material that’s easy to spread and smooth. That’s where plasticity comes in – how well the lime putty or hydrated lime mix can be shaped without cracking.

Lime putty offers superior plasticity due to its fine particle size and high water retention. It gives a better, smoother finish with fewer coats. Hydrated lime, on the other hand, is stiffer and less forgiving, requiring more coats for an even finish.

The open time, or how long the plaster remains workable before setting, varies between the two. Lime putty has a longer open time, giving you more leeway to spread and smooth the coat. Hydrated lime sets faster, so you’ve got to work quicker.

For base coats on high-porosity substrates, lime putty is your friend. It stays put, allowing for better suction and adhesion. For fine finish coats, hydrated lime can give a neater edge, but it requires more skill and patience due to its shorter open time.

Practical Mixing Guidance and Test Batches

Mixing lime putty or hydrated lime isn’t rocket science, but it does take some practice to get right. Start by checking the manufacturer’s datasheet for recommended ratios. Remember, these are just guidelines – you might need more or less water depending on the aggregate size and atmospheric humidity.

For lime putty, a good starting point is 3 parts lime putty to 1 part water by volume. For hydrated lime, it’s typically 2 parts hydrated lime to 1 part water. But don’t take these as gospel – always do test batches to dial in your consistency.

When mixing, use a clean bucket and a strong, sturdy paddle mixer. Add the dry material first, then slowly add the water while mixing at low speed. Once combined, mix on high speed for a few minutes to ensure a homogeneous mix. Let it rest for 10-15 minutes before remixing briefly.

Always do test batches in varying conditions – different temperatures, humidity levels, and aggregate sizes. This way, you’ll know exactly what works best for your specific job site.

Back to top ↑

Early handling strength is generally lower for traditional lime putty mixes but improves as carbonation progresses; hydrated lime mixes can reach usable handling strength sooner depending on drying and mix design. Use simple on-site indicators—tack tests, gentle rattle or knock checks, and small pull tests—to judge when a coat is ready for the next stage rather than relying on arbitrary times.

Curing conditions control strength gain for both types: avoid rapid drying or heat that can cause shrinkage cracks, and avoid prolonged saturation that slows carbonation or hydraulic reactions. For long-term durability consider substrate porosity and exposure—pick the system that matches expected moisture cycles and, if unclear, check manufacturer guidance or local standards for compatible lime classes and curing recommendations.

Early strength versus long-term carbonate hardening

Lime putty and hydrated lime differ in their early handling strength. Lime putty, due to its hydraulic setting, gains strength quickly after mixing. You can test this by gently pressing the plaster with your finger; if it holds a clear imprint without crumbling, it’s gaining strength.

Long-term, both types harden through carbonation. This process turns lime into limestone, increasing hardness and cohesion. But lime putty’s hydraulic setting also contributes to its long-term strength. Adding pozzolans like fly ash or silica fume can boost this effect in hydrated lime.

Remember, early strength doesn’t guarantee long-term durability. Both types need time to fully carbonate for best performance.

Role of aggregates, pozzolans and reinforcement

Sand grading affects final strength. Coarse sand gives higher early strength but lower long-term strength. Fine sand does the opposite. Use a mix for best results.

Pozzolans like fly ash or silica fume improve both types’ strength over time. They react with lime to form additional cementitious materials. Add them at 10-20% by weight of lime for optimal effect.

Fibers or hair (like horsehair) reinforce plaster, reducing shrinkage cracks. Use them sparingly; too much can weaken the mix.

Back to top ↑

Prepare the substrate, key the scratch coat appropriately, and match coat sequencing to the lime type: putty-based mixes often tolerate longer intercoat intervals and finer finishes, while hydrated lime mixes can require closer timing control. Keep substrate moisture consistent and follow product guidance for lag times between scratch, float, and finish coats rather than guessing intervals.

Mix design affects everything—start with small batches to dial in water, sand, and any pozzolans and note how the mix behaves through scratch, brown, and finish stages. Protect work from wind and sun, damp-cure or mist where appropriate, and use test patches to confirm adhesion and finish quality before scaling up to whole walls.

Traditional multi-coat lime plaster workflow

For historic repairs and traditional plasters, a multi-coat approach is typically used with lime putty. This method ensures a strong, durable finish that mimics the original historic plasters.

Scratch coat: Apply the first coat thinly and evenly, using a hawk and trowel. The scratch coat should be thin enough to key into the substrate but thick enough to provide a solid base for subsequent coats.

Float coat: After the scratch coat has begun to set (usually after 24-48 hours), apply the float coat. This layer is thicker and helps level out any imperfections from the scratch coat. Use a float trowel or darby to spread and level the plaster.

The final finish coat is applied once the float coat has set (usually after another 24-48 hours). This layer is typically thin and smooth, providing the final aesthetic finish. Staging these coats allows each layer to bond properly with the one beneath it, ensuring a strong, long-lasting plaster.

Mixed or hydrated-lime workflows for modern applications

Hydrated lime can be used in pre-mixed or hot-mixed systems, providing a quick and convenient solution for modern plastering needs. Here’s how to achieve consistent results:

Pre-mixed systems: Purchase ready-to-use hydrated lime plasters from reputable suppliers. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for application and timing. These systems are ideal for DIY homeowners as they require minimal preparation.

Hot-mixed systems: Mix hydrated lime with water and aggregates on-site, following a specified recipe. Apply the plaster while it’s still warm (around 140-160°F or 60-71°C) for optimal workability. Hot-mixing allows for greater control over the mix design but requires more skill and equipment.

Regardless of the system used, ensure each coat is applied at the right time to allow proper curing and bonding. Follow the same scratch, float, finish sequence as traditional multi-coat plasters, adjusting timings based on temperature and humidity conditions.

Back to top ↑

For historic restoration, lime putty often better matches traditional textures and breathability, whereas hydrated lime can be a practical choice for quicker repair work or thicker coats in less-sensitive settings. Assess the project priority—authenticity, speed, or ease—and consult conservation guidance or product documentation where authenticity matters.

New-build breathable systems and interior decorative work each have different demands: choose the lime type that suits substrate softness, required vapor permeability, and desired finish quality. For DIY patches and small jobs, favor approaches with predictable mixing and short test patches; if unsure, verify product suitability and recommended uses with supplier instructions.

Conservation and historic fabric

When working on period buildings, authenticity is key. Lime putty is often the go-to choice due to its traditional nature and compatibility with historic plasters.

Lime putty’s slow carbonation process allows it to breathe and move with the substrate over time, minimizing cracking and damage. This makes it ideal for preserving the original character of old buildings.

Use lime putty when you want to maintain the historic integrity of a project. It’s perfect for matching existing textures and ensuring long-term durability.

However, if you need to apply thicker coats or require easier workability, consider using hydrated lime mixed with sand in your repairs. But remember, it may not match the original plaster’s texture as closely.

New construction and breathable systems

In modern builds, both lime putty and hydrated lime have their places. For exterior or interior breathable shells, lime-based plasters are excellent choices.

Hydrated lime can be advantageous in new constructions due to its consistency and ease of use. It sets faster than lime putty, allowing for quicker progress on-site. Plus, it’s compatible with existing soft substrates like timber lath or light-gauge metal studs.

However, keep in mind that hydrated lime has a shorter open time compared to lime putty. This means you’ll need to work faster once the plaster is mixed.

Consider using blended systems for new builds. Combine lime putty with hydrated lime or other aggregates to create a plaster tailored to your specific project needs and substrates.

DIY and small repairs

For DIY homeowners, ease of use is crucial. Both lime putty and hydrated lime can be used for small repairs or decorative plasters, but they have different handling characteristics.

Lime putty offers more open time, allowing you to work at a slower pace. It’s great for those new to plastering as it provides some leeway. However, it does take longer to set and harden fully.

Hydrated lime, on the other hand, sets faster and is easier to mix. It’s perfect for quick repairs or when you need a consistent finish across multiple coats. But remember, its shorter open time means you’ll need to work more quickly once the plaster is mixed.

For small DIY jobs, consider your project’s specific needs. If speed and consistency are priorities, go with hydrated lime. But if you prefer a slower pace and longer working time, choose lime putty. Always remember that safety comes first – if in doubt, consult a professional.

Back to top ↑

Bring proper PPE—alkali-resistant gloves, eye protection, and a respirator for dusty work—and tools like hawks, darbies, steel trowels, a mechanical mixer, brushes, and clean buckets. Keep a clean sands supply, check sand gradation, and store lime products sealed and labeled; if you need confirmation about material grading or lime class ask the supplier for lab data or a conformity certificate.

Materials to list before starting include the lime type specified, compatible sand, any pozzolans or hydraulic binders planned, and backup stock for weather delays. Cross-check standards and local code references with product data sheets and request manufacturer instructions for mix guidance, and run simple workability and open-time tests on-site before full application.

Lime products can be caustic and dusty—use gloves, goggles, and dust control measures and consult safety data sheets for first-aid and handling specifics. Minimize airborne dust by damp-mixing, use local exhaust or fresh air ventilation, and keep splash protection available when transferring or slaking lime.

Store lime in sealed containers, rotate stock to avoid spoilage, and follow local rules for disposal of waste plaster; check SDS and local waste guidance if unsure about neutralization or disposal routes. Consider environmental factors like transport miles, material longevity, and carbonation over life—balance safety and sustainability choices by selecting appropriate products and working to reduce waste and emissions on the job.

Handling risks and first-aid

Both lime putty and hydrated lime can cause skin and eye irritation due to their alkalinity. Always wear gloves, goggles, and a respirator when handling.

Caustic burns are common. If lime gets on your skin or in your eyes, rinse immediately with plenty of water. Seek medical attention if symptoms persist.

Dust can cause respiratory irritation. Keep work areas well-ventilated and avoid generating dust by using damp-mixing methods.

Environmental footprint and sustainability factors

The environmental impact of lime products starts at the quarry. Embodied energy is lower for locally sourced limes, so consider your project’s proximity to quarries.

Lime carbonation can offset some emissions over time, but this process takes years. For immediate benefits, use limes with lower embodied energy and transport distances.

Durability matters too. Lime plasters last longer than cement-based alternatives, reducing waste and maintenance needs. Breathable systems also help regulate humidity, preventing mold growth and structural damage.

Long-term durability can improve project sustainability. Choose the lime product that best suits your project’s needs and local conditions to maximize longevity.

Back to top ↑