Best Places to Buy Paint Online: Color Match, Shipping, and Return Tips

Online paint shopping offers unmatched convenience and a broad selection but comes with shipping delays and the risk of color mismatches due to screen distortion. In contrast, in-store visits allow for immediate color testing under various lighting conditions and professional advice, though you’re limited by shelf availability and may miss out on online deals.

DIY projects rely heavily on accurate color matching, so plan your shopping strategy accordingly. Use online platforms when you need a wide range of colors or scheduled deliveries, but visit stores first for critical color accuracy and hands-on testing. Compare promos and return policies, use color-matching tools with caution, and take detailed notes on lighting conditions to avoid mistakes.

Online Advantages and Trade-offs

Convenience is a key advantage of online shopping; you can order anytime from your device and have home delivery. However, screen colors may differ from real-life hues, making it hard to match the exact shade you want.

Lack of hands-on interaction with paint samples means you miss out on testing under different lighting conditions, crucial for accurate color matching. This can lead to unexpected results when the paint dries on your walls.

When to Choose In-store Pickup or Local Retailers

For large projects, visiting a store first is beneficial as it provides professional advice and access to color testers under various lighting conditions.

Local stores offer better service for custom tints or specialty paints, allowing on-site mixing with immediate feedback. This is especially useful for contractors working with specific shades regularly.

In-store visits also simplify returns if the color isn’t right when it dries. Local stores often have more flexible pickup options and might offer discounts on bulk purchases.

Back to top ↑

Online sellers break into brand-direct stores, national paint brands, online-only retailers, and marketplaces, and each type stocks paint, primers, stains, and accessories in different ways. Look for concrete sample offerings from each seller, including peel-and-stick color samples, swatches, fan decks, and small jars or cans, and note any limits or geographic restrictions. Expect clear differences in list price, sale pricing, bulk options, shipping costs, and perks, and call out who stocks samples, swatches, fan decks, and full cans.

Understanding the landscape helps you plan sampling and budgeting before you start work, so you don’t overspend chasing deals or end up with wrong color swatches. It also highlights practical choices for a DIYer, like in-store pickup, returns on online orders, and whether color-matching tools work online or only in person, saving trips and headaches on a messy paint project.

Brand Direct Stores

When you buy from brand direct stores like Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams, you’re getting paint straight from the source. These places offer a wide range of products including paints, primers, stains, and related accessories.

Online orders typically come with restrictions on shipping versus in-store pickup. Shipping costs can add up, especially for larger items or bulk purchases. Look out for promotions that might lower these costs or provide free shipping during certain times of the year.

Pricing at brand direct stores often includes both regular list prices and promotional discounts. Keep an eye out for sales events where you might find significant savings on full cans or kits, making it a good time to stock up if you’re planning a big project.

Big-box and Marketplace Options

For those looking for variety and convenience, big-box stores like Home Depot and Lowe’s offer extensive paint selections alongside other home improvement products. These retailers also have a strong online presence through their websites and marketplaces such as Amazon.

The range of products includes everything from basic paints to specialized finishes. Shipping options vary widely, with some offering free shipping on orders over a certain amount or during specific promotions. In-store pickup is often available for those who prefer it.

Prices at these outlets can be competitive, especially when considering bulk purchases or seasonal sales. They frequently run promotions that beat brand direct stores on cost and speed of delivery, making them a good choice if you’re looking to save money or get your supplies quickly.

Specialty and Indie Online Retailers

For DIY enthusiasts seeking unique color lines or eco-friendly options, specialty and indie online retailers offer a curated selection of paints. These stores often carry hard-to-find colors and provide detailed information about the products they sell.

Sample offerings can include peel-and-stick swatches, fan decks, and small sample jars, allowing you to test different shades before committing to larger quantities. Shipping options vary but are generally reliable for getting your samples or full cans delivered directly to your doorstep.

These retailers often highlight the quality and sustainability of their products, making them a go-to source if you’re looking for something specific that major brands might not carry. Their customer service is usually top-notch, providing personalized advice on color matching and product selection.

Back to top ↑

Modern color matching involves hardware like spectrophotometers, software tools such as smartphone apps, and human consultations. These methods offer speed and convenience but have limitations due to lighting conditions, surface types, and finish sheen. Treat digital matches as preliminary steps and always verify with paint swatches.

Online consultations often include video calls, swatches, and room renders. Costs vary by retailer and service level. Incorrect matches can lead to wasted materials and time on-site, so testing is crucial.

Using Color Apps and Spectrometers (Colorreader, Brand Apps)

Apps like Colorreader match colors from photos or scans but require consistent lighting for accuracy. Spectrophotometers provide precise measurements suitable for critical projects.

For DIY projects, use apps indoors with neutral light or natural daylight. Solid colors yield better results than patterns or textures.

Virtual Consultations and Designer Services

Virtual consultations offer personalized advice through video calls, including mood boards and color suggestions tailored to your space.

Prepare by gathering room photos under consistent lighting and sharing existing samples for matching. Clearly communicate your desired style and feel.

Pricing ranges from free basic sessions to detailed packages costing around $50-$150 based on retailer and designer expertise.

Testing Strategies for True Color (Samples, Peel-and-stick)

Order samples from your chosen paint brand and test them in the intended lighting conditions. Use peel-and-stick swatches or wet samples for accurate tests without damaging walls.

Apply at least two coats of sample paint to mimic real coverage. Test in corners and under different light sources. Stop and reassess if results vary; consider professional help if unsure.

Back to top ↑

Select products, add them to your cart, and proceed to checkout either as a guest or by logging into an existing account for a personalized experience.

Setting up an account is quick; verify your email address and save billing and shipping information for future orders. This streamlines the process and allows you to manage preferences easily.

Purchase options include credit cards, digital wallets, and occasionally cash on delivery (COD). Special arrangements are available for bulk or contractor accounts. Order tracking provides real-time updates and expected delivery windows, helping you plan accordingly.

Understanding these steps is crucial for maintaining project timelines, especially when deadlines are tight and access to the site is limited.

Creating an Account and Managing Orders

To create an account, visit the retailer’s website and click ‘Sign Up’ or ‘Create Account.’ Enter your email address and a secure password. Confirm your email by clicking the link sent to you.

Your profile allows you to save billing and shipping addresses for quick checkout. Track past orders and view order history here for repeat purchases.

Manage account settings under ‘My Account’ or similar section. Update your password, add payment methods, and adjust other preferences like email notifications or marketing communications.

Payment Methods, Invoices, and Contractor Pricing

Most retailers accept major credit cards, debit cards, and digital wallets. Invoice options are available for larger orders or professional accounts.

If you’re a contractor, look for special pricing tiers designed for bulk purchases or trade discounts by creating a business account on the retailer’s site.

Contact customer service to set up an invoice account allowing payment after receiving your order. This is useful for large quantity orders.

Common Ordering Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

Avoid common mistakes when ordering paint online:

• Mistake: Not checking tint mix times can delay your project. Solution: Confirm the lead time for custom color mixes before placing an order.
• Mistake: Choosing the wrong sheen or volume can mean extra trips to the store. Solution: Measure your space accurately and select a finish that suits both the surface and function of the room.
• Mistake: Entering incorrect SKU numbers or color codes can result in the wrong paint arriving. Solution: Double-check all details before finalizing your order.

The fastest way to correct mistakes on-site is to call customer service immediately and request a modification or return if possible.

Back to top ↑

Shipping policies vary widely, often including flat-rate pricing for small orders and weight-based charges for larger items like full cans of paint. Hazardous materials rules apply to solvent-based products and sometimes empty containers, with regional or carrier limits that can delay shipments or require alternative methods.

Delivery windows are crucial as standard timelines may extend during peak demand or adverse weather conditions. Real-time tracking and carrier notifications help you plan your project without unexpected pauses. Upon delivery, check packaging for damage immediately upon arrival, verify the delivery, look for leaks, inspect cans thoroughly, and know who to contact if issues arise.

Shipping Paint Safely and Hazard Restrictions

VOCs and flammable tints can limit shipping options. Carriers may impose restrictions on how these items are packaged and shipped, including specific packaging rules to avoid delays or additional fees.

To ensure safe transit, check the retailer’s guidelines on hazardous materials before placing an order. This includes understanding what types of paints and primers are restricted by region or carrier. Typically, you’ll need to follow specific packaging rules to avoid delays or additional fees.

Pickup Timelines, In-store Collection, and Proof Requirements

To avoid delays when picking up your order in-store or curbside, have proof of purchase or order confirmation ready, such as an email receipt or digital order number.

Orders placed online for pickup typically have a hold time of around 24 to 48 hours. Same-day pickup might be available at some stores, depending on the time of day you place your order.

To coordinate your pickup smoothly, plan ahead and check the store’s operating hours. Arriving during off-peak times can help you avoid long lines and ensure a quicker transaction.

Expedited Delivery and Same-day Options

For urgent orders, some retailers offer expedited delivery or same-day pickup options at additional costs to cover rush tinting and faster shipping.

To take advantage of these services, place your order well before the cut-off time for next-day or same-day service. Rush orders can be more expensive but are worth it if you’re on a tight schedule.

Before opting for expedited delivery, check with the retailer about any additional requirements or restrictions that may apply to avoid unexpected delays.

Back to top ↑

To qualify for a refund or exchange, adhere to specific deadlines. Online orders often have different return windows than in-store purchases. Be prepared for potential restocking fees, depending on the retailer’s policy.

Keep your proof of purchase and ensure items are returned in their original packaging. Refunds typically go to the original payment method; store credit may be offered as an alternative.

Understanding these rules is crucial when managing a job site where time efficiency is key. Follow this process: start with online or in-store purchases, save receipts, photograph packaging, and ship items back promptly. Clarify who bears shipping costs to avoid unexpected charges.

Returning Samples vs. Full Cans

Retailers often have different policies for returning samples compared to full cans of paint. Unopened color samples can typically be returned within a short window, usually around 14 days from purchase.

For opened containers or partially used testers, the return period is much shorter, often only 7 days, and may come with restocking fees. Full cans of paint are less likely to be accepted for returns unless there’s an issue like damage or incorrect color mix.

Always check the specific retailer’s policy before purchasing to avoid disappointment. Keep your receipt handy when initiating a return request online or in-store.

Damaged or Incorrect Orders: Claims and Documentation

If you receive damaged paint cans or an incorrect order, act quickly. Start by taking clear photos of the damage or mismatched items along with their packaging.

Contact customer service immediately using the retailer’s website or phone number provided on your receipt. Provide them with your order number and detailed descriptions of the problem.

Preserving the original packaging is crucial for claims, especially if you need to return damaged goods. Follow up regularly until the issue is resolved.

Back to top ↑

Test paint colors in various lighting conditions using swatches on actual walls or large sample boards under daylight, incandescent, and LED lights to observe undertone shifts. Prime surfaces when necessary, apply the recommended number of coats, and plan your coat order (base vs topcoats) to control color consistency and avoid lap marks.

Wear personal protective equipment (PPE), ventilate indoor spaces, and store open cans by season. Label samples with date and lighting conditions during testing. Use a simple grid for easy comparison and note wall texture and lighting angle when photographing swatches.

Storing Samples and Mixed Paint Safely

Store paint samples and mixed paints in cool, dry places away from direct sunlight and extreme temperatures. Seal partial cans tightly to prevent moisture buildup.

In humid climates, store open cans upside down with lids sealed tight to keep air out. In freezing conditions, store indoors or in a heated garage to avoid cracking due to expansion.

Separate latex and oil-based paints as they have different storage needs. Label all samples clearly with the date and lighting conditions used during testing for future reference.

Avoiding Common Color Mistakes (Lighting, Undertones)

Understand how light sources can alter paint colors. Test under natural daylight and various artificial lights to see undertone shifts.

• Mistake: Not considering adjacent finishes. Fix: Test your chosen color next to existing or planned finishes for harmony.
• Mistake: Ignoring the impact of artificial lighting. Fix: Use a variety of light sources, including natural daylight and different types of bulbs.
• Mistake: Relying solely on digital screens for color selection. Fix: Always test physical samples in the actual space.

If you make a poor choice, repaint with a neutral tone that complements existing colors until you can reassess and choose a better match.

Seasonal Product Picks and Working Conditions

Select paints designed for high humidity in summer months to prevent bubbling or peeling. In winter, opt for cold-weather formulas that dry faster at lower temperatures.

For exterior work, choose mildew-resistant paints during humid seasons and UV-resistant options for sunny climates. Indoor projects benefit from low-VOC paints to minimize odor and improve indoor air quality.

Seasonal changes can affect paint drying times and performance. Adjust your application techniques—use thinner coats in high humidity and ensure proper ventilation when painting indoors.

Back to top ↑