Rolled Roofing vs Shingles: Which Is Best for Your Home?

Understanding Rolled Roofing vs. Shingles

Choosing the right roof covering is essential, especially for low-slope roofs. The debate between rolled roofing and shingles is a common one among homeowners and contractors alike. Each option offers distinct advantages and challenges, depending on your roofing needs.

This guide delves into the specifics of asphalt roll roofing and asphalt shingles, aiming to provide you with all the information necessary to make an informed decision.

Whether you’re considering the cost-effective benefits of rolled roofing or the durability of shingles, understanding these materials is key to protecting your home from the elements.

Main Content

Introduction to Rolled Roofing and Shingles

Rolled Roofing

Definition and Uses: Rolled roofing, or mineral-surfaced roll roofing, consists of asphalt-based materials. It’s an economical choice primarily designed for low-slope residential roofs or outbuildings like sheds and workshops.
Advantages:

Cost-Effectiveness: Generally less expensive than shingles.
Simplicity of Installation: Can be installed quickly, often in a single layer, reducing labor costs.

Drawbacks:

Aesthetic Appeal: Offers fewer color and style options compared to shingles.
Durability: Typically has a shorter lifespan than shingles, lasting about 10 years.

Asphalt Shingles

Definition and Uses: Asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing material for residential homes, suitable for a wide range of roof slopes but ideal for steeper ones.
Advantages:

Variety: Available in numerous colors, styles, and textures.
Durability: Can last 20 years or more with proper maintenance.

Drawbacks:

Cost: More expensive upfront than rolled roofing.
Installation Complexity: Requires more time and skill to install properly.

Choosing the Right Material for Your Roof

Considerations for Low-Slope Roofs

Weather Resistance: Rolled roofing offers better water resistance for low-slope roofs, which are more prone to water pooling.
Budget Constraints: If budget is a primary concern, rolled roofing might be the more favorable option.

Considerations for Steeper Roofs

Aesthetic Preferences: For homeowners concerned with curb appeal, shingles provide a wider range of options to enhance the home’s exterior.
Long-Term Investment: Despite the higher initial cost, shingles offer greater longevity and could be a more cost-effective solution over time.

Conclusion and Next Steps

Deciding between rolled roofing and shingles depends on several factors, including the slope of your roof, aesthetic preferences, budget, and long-term roofing needs.

Rolled roofing is a practical, cost-effective solution for low-slope roofs, offering ease of installation and sufficient protection for less demanding applications. On the other hand, asphalt shingles are a versatile, durable choice for a wide range of roof slopes, offering enhanced aesthetic appeal and longevity.

For those planning a roofing project, it’s important to weigh these considerations carefully. Consulting with a roofing professional can provide personalized advice based on the specific requirements of your home.

Ultimately, the right choice will ensure your roof is well-equipped to protect your home for years to come, making it a crucial aspect of your home maintenance and improvement efforts.

Understanding Rolled Roofing

Rolled roofing, a pragmatic solution for covering low-slope roofs, is fashioned from the same materials as asphalt shingles but comes in large, convenient rolls. This guide aims to explore rolled roofing in depth, covering its appearance, longevity, and cost-effectiveness.

By understanding the pros and cons of this roofing material, homeowners can make informed decisions that align with their budget, aesthetic preferences, and functional needs.

Main Content

Definition and Composition of Rolled Roofing

What is Rolled Roofing?

Basics: Rolled roofing is a mineral-surfaced roofing product made of asphalt. Unlike shingles, it comes in rolls that can cover large areas quickly.
Composition: It consists of a base mat made from organic felt or fiberglass that is coated with asphalt and then covered with mineral granules.

Pros and Cons of Rolled Roofing

Advantages

Cost-Effectiveness: It’s generally cheaper than shingles, making it a budget-friendly option for many homeowners.
Ease of Installation: The roll format allows for quick and straightforward installation, reducing labor costs.

Disadvantages

Aesthetic Appeal: Rolled roofing offers a more utilitarian appearance, which may not suit those looking for style variety.
Durability: With a shorter lifespan, it may need replacing more frequently than other roofing materials.

Key Considerations for Using Rolled Roofing on Low-Slope Roofs

Water Resistance: Ideal for low-slope or nearly flat roofs due to its ability to offer a solid, continuous surface that minimizes leaks.
Application: Often used for workshops, sheds, garages, and other auxiliary buildings where aesthetics are a secondary concern.

Enhancing the Look of Rolled Roofing

Paint or Coatings: While naturally less appealing, the appearance of rolled roofing can be improved with special paints or coatings designed for roofing materials.
Strategic Use: Combining it with other materials or using it on less visible parts of the roof can mitigate its aesthetic limitations.

Understanding the Lifespan of Rolled Roofing

Expected Longevity: Typically lasts about 10 years, although this can vary based on climate and maintenance.
Maintenance Tips: Regular inspections and prompt repairs can extend its useful life, protecting the underlying structure from water damage.

Cost Comparison with Other Materials

Initial Outlay: While the upfront cost is lower than shingles, the potential need for more frequent replacements should be considered in long-term budgeting.
Value Proposition: It offers a good value for specific applications, such as covering low-slope roofs where water pooling is a concern.

Conclusion and Next Steps

Rolled roofing stands out as a cost-effective, straightforward solution for roofing needs, particularly suited to low-slope or flat roofs. While it may not win any awards for beauty, its practicality and ease of installation make it a viable option for many projects.

Homeowners should weigh the aesthetic and longevity drawbacks against the immediate cost savings and ease of application.

If you’re considering rolled roofing for your next project, it’s essential to evaluate how its characteristics align with your specific needs. For those looking to enhance the aesthetic appeal, exploring paint and coating options could be worthwhile.

Remember, the longevity of your roof can be significantly impacted by regular maintenance and the quality of the installation. Consulting with a roofing professional can provide further insights, ensuring that your roofing choice meets both your functional and financial criteria effectively.

Exploring Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are a cornerstone in residential roofing, renowned for their versatility, durability, and cost-effectiveness. They cater to a myriad of architectural styles and homeowner preferences with their wide range of colors and designs.

This guide aims to provide a comprehensive overview of asphalt shingles, touching on their appearance, longevity, and how they stand as a budget-friendly option for those in the market for roof replacement or installation.

Main Content

Introduction to Asphalt Shingles

Popularity and Versatility

Overview: Asphalt shingles are the most commonly used roofing material in the U.S., celebrated for their adaptability across different roof styles and climates.
Types: They come in several types, including architectural (dimensional) shingles, 3-tab shingles, and luxury (designer) shingles, each offering unique benefits.

Types of Asphalt Shingles

Architectural Shingles

Description: These are thicker and offer a multidimensional appearance, mimicking the look of wood shake or slate.
Benefits: Enhanced durability and a longer lifespan compared to 3-tab shingles.

3-Tab Shingles

Description: Known for their flat appearance, with three tabs per shingle, creating a uniform look.
Benefits: More cost-effective and easier to install, making them a popular choice for those on a budget.

Designer Shingles

Description: The premium option, designed to replicate high-end materials like slate and cedar shake.
Benefits: Offer the highest level of aesthetic appeal, along with superior durability.

Aesthetic Appeal of Asphalt Shingles

Color and Style Variety: Asphalt shingles are available in a spectrum of colors and styles, enabling homeowners to choose options that best fit their home’s architectural design and color scheme.
Customization: The wide selection allows for a high degree of personalization, enhancing curb appeal and potentially increasing home value.

Longevity and Maintenance of Asphalt Shingles

Durability: Properly installed and maintained asphalt shingles can last 20-30 years, depending on the quality and type.
Maintenance Tips: Regular inspections, cleaning, and prompt repairs can extend the life of a shingle roof, ensuring it remains effective in protecting the home.

Cost Comparison: Asphalt Shingles vs. Rolled Roofing

Initial Investment: Although more expensive upfront than rolled roofing, asphalt shingles offer a better return on investment due to their longer lifespan and aesthetic contributions.
Overall Value: The balance of cost, durability, and appearance makes asphalt shingles a cost-effective choice for many homeowners, providing a solid middle ground between affordability and quality.

Conclusion and Next Steps

Asphalt shingles represent a balanced roofing option that combines aesthetic versatility, durability, and cost-effectiveness. Their ability to complement a wide range of architectural styles, coupled with a lifespan that can reach up to 30 years with proper care, makes them a preferred choice for residential roofing.

Whether opting for the budget-friendly 3-tab shingles, the durable architectural ones, or the luxurious designer shingles, homeowners have a wealth of options to meet their roofing needs and preferences.

For those contemplating a new roof, considering the long-term impact of your choice on both the appearance and protection of your home is crucial. Exploring the different types of asphalt shingles and understanding their maintenance requirements can help ensure that your roofing decision aligns with your aesthetic desires and budgetary constraints.

Consulting with a roofing professional can further aid in navigating these options, ensuring that your investment enhances your home’s value and stands the test of time.

Comparing Durability and Performance: Rolled Roofing vs. Shingles

The durability and performance of roofing materials are crucial factors for homeowners considering roofing projects. Asphalt roll roofing and asphalt shingles each have their own strengths and weaknesses when it comes to weathering the elements and providing long-term protection for your home.

This guide compares the two in terms of durability, performance under various weather conditions, and overall impact resistance, helping you make a well-informed choice based on the specific needs of your roofing project.

Main Content

Durability of Asphalt Roll Roofing

Weather Resistance

Extreme Conditions: Rolled roofing is lauded for its ability to withstand extreme temperatures and harsh weather conditions, making it a solid option for areas prone to such climates.
Protection Against Leaks: Its seamless application offers superior protection against water leaks, an important consideration for flat or low-sloped roofs.

Impact on Longevity

Potential Vulnerabilities: While durable, rolled roofing may be more susceptible to punctures and wear over time, which can compromise its integrity if not promptly addressed.

Durability of Asphalt Shingles

Resistance to Environmental Factors

Wind and Rain: Asphalt shingles are designed to resist high winds and heavy rainfall, though they can be more prone to damage under extreme conditions compared to rolled roofing.
Fire and Impact Resistance: High-quality shingles are treated for added fire resistance and are capable of withstanding impacts from hail and debris.

Longevity and Maintenance

Lifespan: Properly installed and maintained asphalt shingles can last 20 to 30 years, significantly longer than most rolled roofing options.
Maintenance Requirements: Regular inspections and maintenance can mitigate potential damage and extend the lifespan of shingle roofs.

Performance Comparison

Suitability for Roof Types

Rolled Roofing: Best for flat or low-sloped roofs where its comprehensive coverage and waterproofing capabilities are most needed.
Shingles: Ideal for pitched roofs due to their ability to efficiently shed water and snow, preventing leaks and moisture damage.

Climatic Considerations

Rolled Roofing: Performs well in both extreme heat and cold, making it versatile for various climate conditions.
Shingles: While generally durable, they may require extra precautions in areas with severe weather patterns, including special installation techniques to prevent wind uplift or damage from heavy rains.

Conclusion and Next Steps

When comparing the durability and performance of rolled roofing versus asphalt shingles, it’s clear that both materials have their place, depending on the roof type, climate, and specific needs of the project.

Rolled roofing offers a cost-effective and durable solution for flat or low-sloped roofs, particularly in extreme weather conditions. On the other hand, asphalt shingles provide a longer lifespan and better aesthetic appeal for pitched roofs, along with the ability to withstand a wide range of environmental challenges when properly maintained.

Before making a decision, evaluate the specific requirements of your roofing project, including climate, roof design, and budget. Consulting with a roofing professional can also provide insights into the best material choice for your home, ensuring a balance between durability, performance, and cost.

Suitability for Different Roof Types

The choice between rolled roofing and shingles is significantly influenced by the type of roof you have. Understanding the suitability of each material for low-slope versus pitched roofs is crucial for ensuring optimal performance and longevity.

This guide will explore the best uses for rolled roofing and shingles, helping you make an informed decision based on the specific needs and requirements of your roof type.

Main Content

Rolled Roofing for Low-Slope Roofs

Ideal Applications

Cost-Effective Solution: Rolled roofing is often recommended for low-slope roofs due to its affordability and practicality in providing effective coverage.
Protection Against Water: Its continuous surface is particularly effective at guarding against water infiltration, an essential feature for roofs with minimal slope.

Advantages

Easy Installation: The straightforward application process makes it a popular choice for less complex roofing projects, such as on sheds or garages.
Economic Choice: Given its lower material and installation costs, rolled roofing can be a budget-friendly option for covering larger, less visible areas.

Shingles for Pitched Roofs

Ideal Applications

Enhanced Water Shedding: Shingles are particularly adept at handling water runoff, making them a better choice for pitched roofs where water and snow need to be efficiently directed away from the roof surface.
Aesthetic Variety: With a wide range of colors and styles available, shingles allow homeowners to customize the look of their roof to match their home’s architecture and design preferences.

Advantages

Durability: Shingles tend to last longer than rolled roofing, especially when properly maintained, providing a durable solution for residential homes.
Protection Against Elements: The overlapping design of shingles offers superior protection against the elements, including wind, rain, and snow.

Choosing the Right Material for Your Roof

Considerations for Low-Slope Roofs

Waterproofing Needs: For roofs with minimal slope, ensuring adequate waterproofing is key. Rolled roofing’s seamless application helps prevent water from pooling and seeping through.
Budget and Visibility: If the roof is not a focal point of your home’s exterior, the cost savings and functionality of rolled roofing might outweigh the need for aesthetic appeal.

Considerations for Pitched Roofs

Aesthetic Impact: Since pitched roofs are more visible, choosing a material that complements your home’s design is important. Shingles offer the versatility needed to enhance curb appeal.
Long-Term Durability: Given the longer lifespan of shingles, they may offer a more cost-effective solution over time, despite the higher initial investment.

Conclusion and Next Steps

The decision between rolled roofing and shingles largely depends on the slope and design of your roof, as well as your specific needs for durability, aesthetics, and budget.

Rolled roofing is a practical, cost-effective choice for low-slope roofs where water resistance is a priority, and aesthetics are secondary. In contrast, shingles are suitable for pitched roofs, offering better protection against water and the elements, along with a variety of styles to boost your home’s appearance.

Before making a decision, consider the specific requirements of your roof type and how each option aligns with your long-term goals for performance and maintenance.

Consulting with a roofing professional can provide valuable insights, helping you choose the right material that ensures your roof is well-protected and enhances the overall value and appeal of your property.

Installation Methods and Considerations

Proper installation is paramount for both asphalt roll roofing and shingles to ensure they provide the maximum protection and longevity for your roof. This guide explores recommended installation techniques for both materials, focusing on achieving proper adhesion, waterproofing, and overall durability.

By understanding these considerations, homeowners and contractors can ensure that roofing projects are completed successfully, providing years of reliable performance.

Main Content

Installing Asphalt Roll Roofing

Preparation and Underlayment

Roof Deck Preparation: Ensure the roof deck is clean, dry, and free of any debris or protruding nails to avoid punctures or imperfections in the rolled roofing.
Underlayment Application: While not always required, installing a layer of roofing felt can provide additional protection against water.

Adhesion and Sealing

Applying Adhesive: Rolled roofing is typically secured with roofing cement or adhesive, spread evenly over the roof deck or atop an underlayment for enhanced adhesion.
Overlapping Seams: Rolls should overlap each other by at least 2 inches to ensure a watertight seal, with the edges sealed using roofing cement to prevent water infiltration.

Installing Asphalt Shingles

Starter Shingles

First Row Installation: Begin with a starter row at the roof’s edge, using specially designed starter shingles or cutting the tabs off regular shingles to create a solid strip that helps prevent water from penetrating the roof’s edge.

Shingle Laying Technique

Overlapping Pattern: Install shingles in an overlapping pattern, starting from the bottom edge of the roof and working upwards, ensuring each row overlaps the one below it to shed water effectively.
Nailing: Shingles should be secured with nails, typically four per shingle, placed in the designated nailing area to resist wind uplift and ensure longevity.

Flashing and Edges

Critical Areas: Install flashing around chimneys, vents, and roof valleys to direct water away from these vulnerable areas.
Edge Treatment: Drip edges at the eaves and rakes can help guide water off the roof and protect the underlying wood from rot.

Considerations for Both Materials

Climate and Weather Conditions: Consider local climate and weather patterns when planning the installation. Certain adhesives and techniques may be more suitable for different temperatures and humidity levels.
Manufacturer’s Instructions: Always follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for both rolled roofing and shingles, as improper installation can void warranties and compromise the roof’s integrity.
Professional Installation: While some homeowners may consider DIY installation, hiring a professional can ensure that the roofing is installed correctly, adhering to building codes and manufacturer recommendations.

Conclusion and Next Steps

The success of a roofing project heavily relies on the correct installation methods for the chosen material. Whether opting for the simplicity and cost-effectiveness of asphalt roll roofing or the durability and aesthetic appeal of shingles, following recommended practices is essential.

Preparation, proper adhesion, and attention to detail can significantly impact the waterproofing and longevity of the roof.

For homeowners planning a roofing project, considering these installation methods and guidelines will help in achieving a durable and effective roof. Consulting with or hiring a professional roofer can further ensure that your roofing material is installed to the highest standards, providing peace of mind and protection for your home for years to come.

Popular Alternatives to Consider

When it comes to roofing materials, homeowners are not limited to asphalt roll roofing and shingles. Alternatives like wood, metal, tile, and slate offer diverse aesthetic appeals, longevity, and performance characteristics that may better suit specific preferences and requirements.

This guide provides a brief overview of these materials, highlighting their unique benefits and considerations to help you explore options beyond the conventional choices.

Main Content

Wood Shingles and Shakes

Aesthetic Appeal

Natural Look: Wood shingles and shakes offer a distinctive natural and rustic appearance, making them a favored choice for homeowners seeking to enhance the charm of traditional or historic homes.
Variety: Available in various wood types, each offering its own color and texture, wood shingles can complement a wide range of architectural styles.

Considerations

Maintenance: Requires regular maintenance to prevent mold, rot, and insect damage.
Durability: While offering natural beauty, wood shingles can be less fire-resistant and might not fare as well in extremely wet climates unless properly treated.

Metal Roofing

Durability and Longevity

Weather Resistance: Metal roofing stands out for its exceptional durability, capable of withstanding extreme weather conditions, from heavy snow to high winds.
Lifespan: With proper installation and maintenance, metal roofs can last 50 years or more, offering significant longevity.

Considerations

Cost: Initially, metal roofing can be more expensive than some traditional materials, but its durability and low maintenance needs can make it more cost-effective in the long run.
Style and Installation: Available in various styles and colors, metal roofing can suit different home designs. Professional installation is recommended to ensure performance.

Tile Roofing

Classic Elegance

Appearance: Tile roofs, whether made from clay or concrete, provide a timeless and elegant look that can add substantial curb appeal and value to a home.
Variety: Comes in a range of colors, shapes, and styles, allowing for customization to match the home’s aesthetic.

Considerations

Weight: Tile is significantly heavier than many other roofing materials, requiring a structurally sound roof to support the weight.
Cost and Installation: Tile roofing is among the more expensive options, and installation should be handled by professionals experienced with tile.

Slate Roofing

Timeless Durability

Longevity: Slate is one of the most durable roofing materials, with a lifespan that can exceed 100 years when properly maintained.
Natural Beauty: Offers a natural, sophisticated appearance with each slate tile having a unique texture and color.

Considerations

Weight and Cost: Like tile, slate is heavy and requires a sturdy structure. It is also one of the most expensive roofing materials, both in terms of materials and installation.

Conclusion and Next Steps

Wood, metal, tile, and slate roofing materials offer compelling alternatives to traditional asphalt roll roofing and shingles, each with its unique set of benefits and considerations.

From the rustic charm of wood shingles to the unbeatable durability of metal and the classic elegance of tile and slate, these options can cater to a wide range of aesthetic preferences and practical requirements.

Before making a decision, it’s important to consider factors such as the climate in your area, the structural capacity of your home, and your budget. Consulting with a professional roofing contractor can provide valuable insights into the best material for your specific situation, ensuring that your choice not only enhances the appearance of your home but also provides lasting protection and value.

The Significance of Professional Installation

When it comes to roofing, the difference between a job done right and one fraught with issues often lies in the installation process. Whether you’re considering rolled roofing or shingles, the expertise and experience of professional roofing contractors play a crucial role in ensuring the integrity and longevity of your roof.

This guide delves into the importance of professional installation, highlighting the risks associated with DIY efforts and the advantages of entrusting your roofing project to experienced professionals.

Main Content

Expertise of Roofing Contractors

Quality Assurance

Experience and Knowledge: Professional roofing contractors possess the experience and knowledge necessary to properly install various types of roofing materials. Their expertise helps prevent common installation mistakes that could lead to leaks, damage, and the need for costly repairs.
Up-to-Date Techniques: Professionals stay updated on the latest installation techniques and materials, ensuring your roof is installed according to the best practices and industry standards.

Risks of DIY Installation

Potential for Mistakes

Compromised Integrity: DIY installation can easily lead to errors, such as improper nailing or inadequate sealing, compromising the roof’s integrity and making it susceptible to water damage and leaks.
Safety Concerns: Roofing work involves risks, such as falls or injuries. Professionals are trained to work safely on roofs, minimizing the risk of accidents.

Advantages of Professional Installation

Warranties and Guarantees

Workmanship Warranty: Many roofing contractors offer warranties on their work, providing homeowners with peace of mind. These warranties can protect against installation-related problems that might occur down the line.
Material Warranty Compliance: Professional installers ensure that the installation complies with the material manufacturers’ specifications, which is often a requirement for the material warranty to be valid.

Time and Effort Savings

Efficiency: Roofing contractors are equipped with the tools, teams, and techniques to complete the job efficiently and correctly, saving homeowners time and effort.
Project Management: Professionals handle all aspects of the roofing project, from obtaining necessary permits to managing waste disposal, streamlining the process for homeowners.

When DIY Might Be Feasible

Skills and Knowledge: For those with a background in construction or roofing, DIY installation might be feasible for smaller projects, such as a shed or garage roof.
Proper Research and Preparation: With adequate research, preparation, and adherence to local building codes, motivated homeowners can successfully tackle certain roofing tasks.

Conclusion and Next Steps

While the appeal of DIY projects lies in the potential for cost savings and personal accomplishment, roofing is an area where professional expertise is invaluable. The benefits of hiring experienced roofing contractors—ranging from quality assurance and safety to warranties and efficient project completion—far outweigh the perceived advantages of DIY installation for most homeowners.

Before embarking on a roofing project, carefully consider the scope of work, your own skills and experience, and the potential risks involved. In many cases, consulting with and hiring a professional roofing contractor will ensure that your roofing project is completed safely, efficiently, and to a high standard, protecting your home and investment for years to come.

Conclusion

In the realm of roofing choices, the decision between rolled roofing and shingles extends beyond simple aesthetics and cost considerations. The granular surface of these materials significantly influences their durability, performance, and suitability for different environments and roof types.

Rolled roofing, with its smoother granular surface, provides effective protection against the elements, making it an ideal option for low-slope roofs where water resistance is paramount. Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, boast a more textured granular surface. This texture not only contributes to the shingles’ aesthetic appeal but also enhances their protective capabilities, making them a versatile choice for a wide range of roof slopes and architectural styles.

Key Considerations for Choosing Roofing Materials

Rolled Roofing: Its smoother, granular surface is specifically designed to offer robust protection for low-slope roofs, making it an excellent choice for areas where water pooling can be a concern.
Asphalt Shingles: The textured granules provide a dual benefit of enhanced protection and aesthetic versatility, suitable for various climates and capable of complementing different home designs.

Making the Decision

When deciding between rolled roofing and shingles, consider the specific requirements of your roofing project, including the roof’s slope, the climate you live in, and your home’s architectural style. The choice should align with your need for durability, aesthetic preference, and weather resistance.

Final Recommendation

For properties with low-slope roofs, especially in regions prone to significant rainfall, rolled roofing emerges as the preferable choice due to its smoother granular surface designed for optimal water resistance.

For homes with steeper roofs or for those seeking a combination of durability, aesthetic appeal, and a higher degree of protection against diverse weather conditions, asphalt shingles are recommended. Their textured granular surface not only offers an additional layer of protection but also a wide range of stylistic options to enhance the home’s curb appeal.

In conclusion, both rolled roofing and shingles serve distinct purposes and cater to different roofing needs. Evaluating the granular surface along with the climate and specific needs of your roof will guide you to the most suitable choice.

Engaging with a roofing professional can provide further insights, ensuring that your selection not only meets your immediate needs but also contributes to the long-term durability and aesthetic appeal of your home.